Journal
Do conference papers and preprints count as scholarly articles for EB-1A?
The EB-1A criterion in 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3)(vi) asks for authorship of scholarly articles in professional or major trade publications or other major media. The USCIS Policy Manual says that a conference paper can qualify when the conference peer reviews accepted presentations and publishes them, sometimes as proceedings. A preprint is a different case: arXiv states that material on it is not peer reviewed by arXiv, and NIH calls preprints typically unreviewed manuscripts.

What does USCIS count as a scholarly article?
A report on original research, experimentation or philosophical discourse, generally peer reviewed by other experts and usually with footnotes, endnotes or a bibliography. The venue must also be a professional or major trade publication or major media.
The regulation, 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3)(vi), accepts "Evidence of the alien's authorship of scholarly articles in the field, in professional or major trade publications or other major media." Under 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3), the evidence must include "a one-time achievement (that is, a major, international recognized award), or at least three of the following" ten criteria, and this is one of the ten.
The USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 2 reads the criterion in two steps. "First, USCIS determines whether the person has authored scholarly articles in the field." The academic definition follows: "a scholarly article reports on original research, experimentation, or philosophical discourse." It is written by a researcher or expert in the field, and "Scholarly articles are also generally peer reviewed by other experts in the field of specialization." In general it should have footnotes, endnotes or a bibliography.
"Second, USCIS determines whether the publication qualifies as a professional publication, major trade publication, or major media publication." For professional journals the factor is the intended audience. For major media it is circulation or readership relative to other media in the field.
A conference paper and a preprint are tested against both steps. The first asks what the text is and whether experts reviewed it. The second asks where it appeared.
When does a conference paper count as a scholarly article?
When the conference peer reviews the submissions and publishes the accepted papers, sometimes as proceedings. The Policy Manual notes that many articles accepted for presentation at conferences are never published.
Footnote 27 of the Policy Manual chapter reads: "While many articles accepted for presentation at conferences do not result in publication, there are conferences that peer review and publish accepted presentations in professional journals (sometimes called proceedings), such that they may qualify as scholarly articles under this criterion."
The footnote names two conditions, and each needs its own evidence. For peer review, that can be the conference's call for papers or published reviewing procedure and the acceptance notice with reviewer comments. For publication, it can be the proceedings volume or journal issue, its publisher and the pages of the paper.
A talk with no published paper, a poster or an abstract in a program book meets neither condition on paper. The footnote speaks of presentations that a conference reviews and then publishes, and the regulation asks for articles in publications.
Do conference proceedings have to qualify as a publication?
Yes. The second step applies to proceedings as to any journal. In a December 19, 2022 decision the AAO found a conference article, printed in a 1,000-copy collection, not shown to be scholarly or in a qualifying venue.
The petitioner in In Re: 23173147 was an embroiderer. The Nebraska Service Center director had found the scholarly articles criterion met. The AAO did "not agree with the Director's determination regarding the scholarly articles criterion."
The record held pages of a book "published in 350 copies, and distributed among regional libraries," articles in a newspaper and a magazine, and an article presented at the 2014 Scientific-Practical International Conference of an Academy of Sciences. According to the record, "all articles of the conference were published in one collection, with a circulation of 1,000 printed copies."
The AAO found "no documentary evidence" that the works were peer reviewed, contained any references to sources or were otherwise considered scholarly. It added that "the record lacks evidence that other scholars have taken notice of the Petitioner's work." On the venues, the petitioner "has not presented adequate documentation confirming they constitute either professional or major trade publications," and the circulation data did not establish major media.
The AAO concluded that "the Petitioner does not meet this criterion" and dismissed the appeal. The decision turned on both steps: the conference article failed as a scholarly article, and the collection was not shown to be a qualifying publication.
How much weight do conference proceedings carry in the final merits determination?
The Policy Manual gives, as an example, articles in particularly highly ranked journals, including published conference proceedings, relative to other journals in the field, for example by the journal's impact factor.
After three criteria are met, the officer weighs the whole record. The Policy Manual lists examples of evidence for that step. The first is a record of articles "in particularly highly-ranked journals (including published conference proceedings) relative to other journals in the field," for example through "evidence the petitioner provides regarding the journal's impact factor." The two-step review is described in the guide on the Kazarian two-step review.
In In Re: 31109673, decided May 17, 2024 on appeal from the Texas Service Center, the petitioner worked in computer science, in AI and machine learning. His "two most-cited articles, a 2008 conference presentation" and a second work, "had received 32 and 13 citations respectively, with the latter last cited in 2018." The AAO wrote that his citations, "both individually and collectively, show that his work has received some recognition in his field," and found no evidence in the record that the total rate of citations to his body of published work is high relative to others in the field.
The same decision looked at the dates. The Google Scholar profile showed "12 of his publications have been cited at least one time," published between 2003 and 2021, "with only two works published in the ten years preceding the filing of the petition in 2023." The appeal was dismissed.
Is a preprint a scholarly article for EB-1A?
The regulation and the Policy Manual chapter on extraordinary ability do not use the word preprint. The chapter describes scholarly articles as generally peer reviewed, and arXiv states that material on it is not peer reviewed by arXiv.
arXiv describes itself as "a curated research-sharing platform open to anyone" that "now hosts more than three million scholarly articles in eight subject areas": physics, mathematics, computer science, quantitative biology, quantitative finance, statistics, electrical engineering and systems science, and economics. Its About page states: "Material is not peer-reviewed by arXiv."
arXiv moderates submissions. Its moderation page says that moderators "evaluate each submission's content and category, following arXiv policies," and expect submissions "to be of scholarly archival interest to the communities they represent." The same page states: "Please note that the arXiv moderation process is not a peer-review process." Moderators "cannot give feedback on the submission."
A preprint can meet most of the description in the Policy Manual: it can report original research, come from a researcher in the field and carry a bibliography. Peer review is the part it lacks at the time of posting. The second step adds the question of the venue, which for a professional journal turns on its intended audience.
The Policy Manual uses the word "generally" for peer review. A petition that relies on a preprint alone has to answer both steps with evidence about that text and that venue.
How does NIH define a preprint?
As "a complete and public draft of a scientific document." NIH describes preprints as typically unreviewed manuscripts and since 2017 has allowed applicants to cite them as interim research products.
The National Institutes of Health set the rule in notice NOT-OD-17-050, released March 24, 2017. It applies to applications submitted for the May 25, 2017 due date and later, and to progress reports submitted on or after May 25, 2017. "Interim Research Products are complete, public research products that are not final." The notice continues: "A common form is the preprint, which is a complete and public draft of a scientific document."
NIH states the status of these texts directly: "Preprints are typically unreviewed manuscripts written in the style of a peer-reviewed journal article." It also notes that "since preprints are not published in peer-reviewed journals, they do not fall under the NIH public access policy."
Authors who post an interim product are told to "Clearly state that the work is not peer-reviewed." A citation of a preprint in an NIH application must include the Digital Object Identifier and the object type, such as preprint or protocol, and information about the version, such as the date it was last modified.
The NIH notice governs grant applications and progress reports. For an EB-1A record it gives a federal agency's wording for what a preprint is: a complete public draft, cited with its version and date, typically not yet reviewed.
What if a preprint is later published in a journal?
Then the journal version is the peer-reviewed article, and the petition cites it with the journal, date and pages. The preprint and the published paper are one work and are counted once.
Each journal sets its own rule for manuscripts first posted as preprints. IAE Review accepts such a manuscript if the editors are expressly informed in the cover letter, and it prohibits simultaneous submission to another publication.
Counting each work once keeps the list consistent with outside databases. In In Re: 16066129, decided May 18, 2021, a chemical engineer's Google Scholar printout identified "fewer than 20 scholarly writings by the Petitioner, including journal articles, conference presentations, patents, and graduate theses." A letter in the record claimed about 50 publications. The AAO wrote that this letter "raises questions," concluded that the issues with the letters in the record diminish their evidentiary weight, and dismissed the appeal.
A list of publications that marks each item by type, such as journal article, paper in peer-reviewed proceedings, preprint or presentation, lets the officer apply footnote 27 to each item without guessing.
Do downloads of a conference paper prove its significance?
Not by themselves. In a July 28, 2023 decision the AAO found that a 2005 conference paper accessed 707 times, with no evidence of citations by other researchers, did not establish a contribution of major significance.
The petitioner in In Re: 27611613 was an assistant professor and researcher in computer science. Under the criterion of original contributions of major significance, 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3)(v), he offered evidence about "his 2005 conference paper."
The AAO wrote that "although he provided evidence that his 2005 conference paper was accessed 707 times, he did not provide evidence that this paper has been cited by any other researchers." The record held no comparative data on access counts for other papers in the field. The evidence had also been submitted for the first time on appeal.
The petitioner met two of the ten criteria, and the appeal was dismissed. The decision names what was missing: citations by other researchers and comparative data for other papers in the field.
Does evaluating conference submissions count as judging the work of others?
It can be offered under the judging criterion. In a May 17, 2024 decision the AAO noted that a 2008 IEEE conference asked all submitting authors to review and did not reserve reviewing for leading scientists.
Criterion 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3)(iv) covers participation as a judge of the work of others in the same or an allied field. In In Re: 31109673 the petitioner had reviewed submissions for the 2008 IEEE Conference on Emerging Technologies and Factory Automation (ETFA).
The record "indicated that manuscript submissions were reviewed by approximately 300 reviewers" and that "all prospective conference participants who submitted their work were asked to review manuscripts submitted by their peers." The AAO added that "there was no indication that the conference reserved such requests for 'leading scientists.'" The appeal was dismissed.
For a conference paper the same record reads differently. A conference that sends submissions to reviewers before acceptance has the review that footnote 27 asks for. Whether it then publishes the accepted papers is the second condition.
Is the rule the same for EB-1B outstanding researchers?
The EB-1B criterion has its own wording: authorship of scholarly books or articles in scholarly journals with international circulation in the academic field. Conference proceedings are tested against that wording.
The text of 8 CFR 204.5(i)(3)(i)(F) reads: "Evidence of the alien's authorship of scholarly books or articles (in scholarly journals with international circulation) in the academic field." The venue test is a scholarly journal with international circulation, in place of the professional or major trade publications or major media of EB-1A.
For EB-1A, 8 CFR 204.5(h)(4) adds: "If the above standards do not readily apply to the beneficiary's occupation, the petitioner may submit comparable evidence to establish the beneficiary's eligibility." For papers in peer-reviewed published proceedings, footnote 27 already states that they may qualify under the scholarly articles criterion itself.
How does IAE Review handle preprints and conference papers?
A manuscript posted as a preprint is accepted if the cover letter discloses the posting. A manuscript based on a published conference paper must say so, be substantially revised and contain at least 30 percent new material.
Under the editorial policy of IAE Review, a manuscript must be original and not previously published to a substantial extent in another publication, "This includes publication as a preprint unless the Editorial Office has been expressly informed." Simultaneous submission to another publication is prohibited. When a manuscript is based on a previously published conference paper, this is disclosed in the cover letter, the revised work must contain substantial changes, and at least 30% of the material must be new.
Original research articles, analytical reviews, practical case studies and methodological developments go to two independent reviewers in anonymized form. The initial screening takes up to 7 business days, every manuscript is screened for improper borrowing with a similarity threshold of 15%, and the decision after review comes within 60 calendar days of submission. The decision is one of four: accept without changes, accept with minor revisions, return for revision and further review, or reject.
Articles are published online in open access under CC BY 4.0, each with a permanent page and a PDF in English and Russian. No article-processing charge is imposed, and authors keep copyright. Authors may post the accepted manuscript or the published version in institutional repositories, on personal websites and in academic social networks with a link to the original publication in IAE Review.
IAE membership is not required and does not affect editorial decisions. Manuscripts in Russian or English are sent through the submission form as DOCX, PDF or LaTeX. Whether an article counts toward a criterion in a petition is decided by USCIS.
Sources
- 8 CFR 204.5, Petitions for employment-based immigrants (eCFR)
- USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 2, Extraordinary Ability
- USCIS Administrative Appeals Office, In Re: 23173147 (December 19, 2022)
- USCIS Administrative Appeals Office, In Re: 31109673 (May 17, 2024)
- USCIS Administrative Appeals Office, In Re: 27611613 (July 28, 2023)
- USCIS Administrative Appeals Office, In Re: 16066129 (May 18, 2021)
- arXiv, About arXiv
- arXiv, Moderation
- National Institutes of Health, NOT-OD-17-050, Reporting Preprints and Other Interim Research Products (March 24, 2017)
Read also
All articles
How long does peer review take, and what decides the wait?
Authors who reported 3,500 review experiences to the SciRev site waited 13 weeks on average for the first decision, and accepted papers spent 17
Can you submit a paper to two journals at the same time?
In most fields the answer is no. The ICMJE Recommendations state that authors should not submit the same manuscript, in the same or different
Can you publish a research paper without a university affiliation?
A university affiliation is not a condition of authorship. The ICMJE Recommendations define an author by four criteria of contributionJournal
Want to publish in IAE Review?
Submit your manuscript in Russian or English as DOCX, PDF or LaTeX through the submission form. Initial decision within 7 business days.

