Expert witnesses

Failure to warn expert witness: what must a warnings opinion rest on?

A failure to warn claim asks whether the manufacturer gave the warning or instruction that a manufacturer exercising reasonable care would have given about a risk it knew or should have known of. The expert who answers that question is tested under Rule 702. On July 17, 2026, in a design defect case over a propane heater, the Fourth Circuit upheld the exclusion of a human factors expert whose warnings opinion lacked product-specific facts and any objective basis.

Hands hold a blank label on a small heater in warm workshop light

What does a failure to warn expert witness do?

The expert addresses whether the product's warnings and instructions told users about a risk the manufacturer knew or should have known of, and whether a different warning or instruction would have changed what happened.

A warning claim has the same structure as other product claims. Under Ohio Revised Code 2307.73(A), the claimant proves by a preponderance of the evidence that the product was defective in one of four ways, one of them inadequate warning or instruction under section 2307.76, that the defect "was a proximate cause of harm," and that the defendant manufactured "the actual product that was the cause of harm." The expert's opinion goes to the first two elements.

A warnings opinion answers three questions. The first is the risk: what it was and when the manufacturer knew or should have known of it. The second is the warning: what the packaging, labels, manual and the product itself said, where, and in what words. The third is the link to the injury: whether a warning that a careful manufacturer would have given would have reached this user in this situation.

The specialists who testify on these questions vary with the product. In the cases discussed below, a metallurgical engineer gave a warnings opinion about a vehicle service manual, a human factors expert about a propane heater, and an engineering expert about a fire blanket. For prescription drugs the question is the content of the label given to physicians.

When is a product defective for inadequate warning under Ohio law?

Under Ohio Revised Code 2307.76(A)(1), when the manufacturer knew or should have known of the risk that allegedly caused the harm and failed to give the warning that a manufacturer exercising reasonable care would have given.

Section 2307.76(A)(1) applies the test at the time the product left the manufacturer's control. Two conditions must both be met. Under (A)(1)(a), the manufacturer knew or, in the exercise of reasonable care, should have known about a risk associated with the product that allegedly caused the harm. Under (A)(1)(b), the manufacturer failed to provide the warning or instruction that a manufacturer exercising reasonable care would have provided, in light of the likelihood that the product would cause that harm and the likely seriousness of the harm.

The second condition sets the frame for the expert. The question is what a reasonably careful manufacturer would have provided, weighed by likelihood and severity, and the expert who says a warning was inadequate explains which risk was missing or understated and what wording, placement or format a careful manufacturer would have used.

If the product is unavailable, section 2307.73(B) lets the claimant prove the defect by "circumstantial or other competent evidence" that establishes it by a preponderance of the evidence. In a warnings case the expert then works from photographs, exemplar units of the same model and copies of the manual and labels.

Does the duty to warn continue after the sale?

In Ohio, yes. Under section 2307.76(A)(2), a product is defective if at a relevant time after it left the manufacturer's control the manufacturer knew or should have known of the risk and failed to provide a post-marketing warning or instruction.

Section 2307.76(A)(2) repeats the two conditions of (A)(1) for the period after sale: the manufacturer knew or should have known of the risk, and it failed to provide the post-marketing warning or instruction that a manufacturer exercising reasonable care would have provided, in light of the likelihood and seriousness of the harm.

A post-sale opinion turns on dates. The expert sets out when the manufacturer learned or should have learned of the risk and what it sent to owners, dealers or service technicians afterwards. In Pineda v. Ford Motor Co., the plaintiff's engineer compared the 2002 service manual with a 2004 Safety Recall Instruction that gave detailed replacement steps.

Later warnings raise an evidence question. Federal Rule of Evidence 407 generally excludes evidence of measures taken after an injury to prove culpable conduct or a need for a warning. In Pineda the Third Circuit held that the district court erred by looking only at Rule 407 and ignoring Rule 703: "Rule 703 is clear that the SRI does not need to be admissible evidence in order for Clauser's opinion" to be admitted. Under Rule 703, an expert may rely on facts or data that experts in the field "would reasonably rely on," even if they are not admissible, and the proponent may disclose otherwise inadmissible facts or data to the jury only if their probative value in helping the jury evaluate the opinion substantially outweighs their prejudicial effect.

Must a manufacturer warn about an open and obvious risk?

Not in Ohio. Section 2307.76(B) provides that a product is not defective for lack of warning or instruction about an open and obvious risk or a risk that is a matter of common knowledge.

Section 2307.76(B) bars the claim for "an open and obvious risk or a risk that is a matter of common knowledge." The statute does not define the terms, so the parties' evidence describes what the user could see and know at the moment of injury.

That evidence is specific to the product. In Near v. Enerco Group, the only warning the Fourth Circuit described on the heater itself was the word "HOT" stamped into the heater's shield. The hangtag and the owner's manual carried the clearance distances. The plaintiff's expert argued that the warnings should have said that clothing could ignite "even without direct contact with the heater or its grate."

A defense expert on obvious risk works with the same materials: what the product looked and felt like in use and what the labels, the manual and the product itself told the user. In Near the court excluded an expert who had never seen the heater in person and had watched it operate only during a videoconference call.

Who must be warned when the product is a prescription drug?

In Ohio, the prescriber. Under section 2307.76(C), an ethical drug is not defective for inadequate warning if the manufacturer gave adequate warning to the prescriber, unless the FDA required that the warning go directly to the patient.

Section 2307.76(C) applies when the manufacturer provided otherwise adequate warning and instruction to the physician or other legally authorized person who prescribes or dispenses the drug, and the federal Food and Drug Administration has not required that the warning be given directly to the ultimate user. The expert's opinion then addresses the label the physician received.

In Wyeth v. Levine, decided on March 4, 2009, the Supreme Court held that federal law did not pre-empt a Vermont failure to warn claim. A clinician injected Phenergan by the IV-push method, the drug entered an artery, Levine developed gangrene, and doctors amputated first her right hand and then her entire forearm. The jury awarded $7,400,000. The label warned of gangrene after inadvertent intra-arterial injection but had no specific warning about IV-push administration.

Justice Stevens wrote that "the manufacturer bears responsibility for the content of its label at all times." The FDA's changes being effected regulation, cited as 21 CFR 314.70(c)(6)(iii)(A) and (C), let Wyeth add or strengthen a warning before FDA approval, and the Court declined to find pre-emption "absent clear evidence that the FDA would not have approved a change to Phenergan's label."

In Merck Sharp & Dohme Corp. v. Albrecht, decided on May 20, 2019, the Court held that whether federal law bars a state-required warning is "one for a judge to decide, not a jury." The manufacturer must show that it "fully informed the FDA of the justifications for the warning required by state law" and that the FDA told it the agency "would not approve changing the drug's label to include that warning."

Must the warnings expert draft and test an alternative warning?

Neither court required it. Pineda v. Ford (3d Cir. 2008) held the engineer did not have to develop or test alternative warnings; Near v. Enerco (4th Cir. 2026) called such steps optional but excluded an opinion with no objective basis.

Jose Pineda was an automobile technician replacing the rear liftgate brackets and hinges on a 2002 Ford Explorer. On July 18, 2002, while he torqued a hinge nut, the liftgate glass shattered and cut his leg. His expert, Craig D. Clauser, P.E., held B.S. and M.S. degrees in metallurgical engineering and material science and had consulted on more than 200 cases involving failures of glass or other ceramics. He opined that the 2002 service manual lacked step-by-step instructions for the replacement and did not warn that following those steps was a safety issue.

The district court excluded Clauser because he admitted he was not a warnings expert, because Rule 407 barred his comparison with the 2004 recall instruction, and because he offered no alternative language, tested no alternative warnings, compared no other manufacturers' manuals and did not test the vehicle. In Pineda v. Ford Motor Co., No. 07-1191, decided on March 24, 2008, the Third Circuit reversed. It cited Rule 702's "liberal policy of admissibility," called a warning "a solution to an engineering problem," and held that "Clauser did not have to develop or test alternative warnings" to give his opinion. The court added that comparing other manufacturers' manuals would likely have made his opinion more reliable.

The two decisions differ in what the expert knew about the product. Clauser's opinion rested on his engineering knowledge of the stresses that make glass fail and on a written comparison of two Ford documents. The expert in Near lacked sufficient product-specific facts and offered no comparison with comparable heaters' warnings and no heater-specific standard.

Why did the Fourth Circuit uphold the exclusion of a human factors expert in 2026?

The expert never saw the heater in person, did no user testing and tied her general ANSI principles to no comparable heater warnings or heater-specific standard. The court called no single step mandatory but required some objective basis.

The product was a Mr. Heater Model MH15T propane tank top heater. A decedent's clothing allegedly ignited near it, and the wrongful death claim under South Carolina law rested on design defect. The packaging told users to read the owner's manual. A removable hangtag set minimum clearances from combustibles of 36 inches from the top and front and 24 inches from the sides, rear and floor, and warned of fire, burn, inhalation and explosion hazards. The manual told users to keep clothing, tents and combustibles at least 30 inches from the heater face. On the heater, "HOT" was stamped into its shield.

The plaintiff's human factors expert, Dr. Nancy Grugle, opined that the warnings were inadequate because they did not expressly identify clothing ignition as a hazard for people standing or walking near the heater. She said a warning should state that clothing could ignite even without direct contact with the heater, give a distance and a time, and state the consequences, including burns, serious injury or death. She relied on the hierarchy of hazard control and on general ANSI warning communication standards. She never saw the heater in person and watched it operate only during a videoconference call, did no user testing, gave no specific content for a clothing ignition warning, compared the warnings with no comparable radiant heater and did not apply the heater-specific standard.

Judge Sherri A. Lydon of the District of South Carolina excluded the opinions as unreliable. In Near v. Enerco Group, Inc., No. 25-1375, decided on July 17, 2026, Judge Benjamin wrote for the Fourth Circuit that the opinion lacked the product-specific facts Rule 702(b) requires, left an "analytical gap" between general principles and the conclusion, and "rested on assertion rather than analysis." The court wrote that "None of this means that a warnings expert must always inspect the product," test user perception or test an alternative warning, but held that "There must be some objective basis" for the conclusion, such as a comparison with comparable radiant heaters or the heater-specific standard. The court affirmed the exclusion and certified to the Supreme Court of South Carolina the question: "Do adequate warnings preclude a design defect claim as a matter of South Carolina law?"

What method does a court expect behind a warnings opinion?

One tied to the product. Courts admitted an opinion built on engineering knowledge of how the glass fails and excluded opinions with no stated method or with no product-specific facts and no objective basis.

Rule 702, as amended effective December 1, 2023, requires the proponent to show that it is more likely than not that the testimony "is based on sufficient facts or data" and "is the product of reliable principles and methods," and that the opinion applies them reliably to the facts of the case. The committee note said that courts treating the sufficiency of an expert's basis as a question of weight had applied Rules 702 and 104(a) incorrectly.

In Koken v. Black & Veatch Construction, Inc., decided on October 14, 2005, the First Circuit reviewed claims over a 1000-degree rated "medium duty" fire blanket used during torch cutting on a construction project in Maine owned by Androscoggin Energy LLC. The engineering expert, Robert Waite, testified that the roll should have carried a warning that the blanket was "inappropriate for cutting operations." The district court allowed his opinion that molten slag on such a blanket creates a fire danger, which rested on his experience, and excluded the opinion about cutting operations. The First Circuit found no abuse of discretion because he "completely failed to articulate any methodology" for judging a blanket's suitability, and with no other evidence that the blanket was unsuitable for cutting, summary judgment for the alleged manufacturer and distributor on the negligence and strict liability claims was affirmed.

Across the three cases the line runs through the product. Pineda's engineer explained the physical mechanism of the failure and compared the manufacturer's own documents. Waite gave a conclusion about suitability with no method. Grugle applied general principles without inspecting the heater, testing users or comparing other products.

What should a warnings expert's file contain?

The report required by Rule 26(a)(2)(B), and behind it the product or an exemplar, every warning on the packaging, labels, manual and the product itself, later warnings or recall instructions, comparable products' warnings and the applicable standards.

A retained expert's report under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 26(a)(2)(B) contains a complete statement of all opinions and the basis and reasons for them, the facts or data considered, exhibits, qualifications with publications from the previous 10 years, a list of cases in which the expert testified at trial or by deposition in the previous 4 years, and the compensation.

The materials list follows from the cases. Near faulted an expert who never saw the product in person and lacked product-specific facts, so the expert inspects the product or an exemplar unit where possible. Near also listed each place a warning appeared: the packaging, the hangtag, the manual and the heater itself, so the expert collects all of them. Pineda let the engineer rely on a later recall instruction under Rule 703, so later warnings and service bulletins belong in the file. Both Pineda and Near pointed to comparable products and standards, so the expert compares the warnings with those of other products of the same kind and names the standard applied.

Where the opinion says users would have read and followed a different warning, Near noted that the expert did not test whether users who saw the existing warnings understood the hazard and used no reliable method to evaluate comprehension, effectiveness or placement. The court did not make such testing mandatory, so the expert either tests comprehension and placement or ties the opinion to another objective basis, such as comparable products' warnings or the product standard.

How does IAE find a failure to warn expert?

In the IAE request, choose the case type Product liability, name the product and state that the claim concerns warnings or instructions. Within 5 business days IAE sends 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates and prior testimony lists.

The product liability expert witness page lists human factors and warnings specialists who address what a user would notice on the label and in the manual, including medical device use errors under the 2026 FDA human factors guidance. The request also asks for the state and court, the side, the expert disclosure deadline, and the parties and their counsel for the conflict check. Please leave out privileged or sealed information.

Within 1 business day IAE replies whether it can search in that field by that deadline. Each candidate confirms in writing that he or she has no ties to the parties or their counsel, and the candidate file includes testimony in the last 4 years and publications in the last 10 years.

The search costs $2,000 per case, paid in advance, and candidate names and CVs come after payment. If no candidate fits, the second search is free; if IAE finds no candidates, it refunds the fee. The expert's hourly rate never depends on the outcome of the case or on the content of testimony. Under the agency option the expert bills through IAE, with $100 per hour added to the hourly rate, 40% added to fixed fees, minimum charges and surcharges, and expenses billed at cost, on one invoice.

IAE is not a law firm. Case strategy and the decision to retain an expert stay with the attorney.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert witnesses

Need an expert witness for your case?

Describe the question, the case type and the court. Within 5 business days you receive 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates and lists of prior testimony.

Expert request

Received

Candidates, rates and prior testimony within 5 business days

Candidates2-3 with CVs
Timeline5 business days
Search$2,000 per case