Expert opinion letters

How many recommendation letters does an NIW petition need?

Neither 8 CFR 204.5 nor Matter of Dhanasar sets a number of recommendation letters for an EB-2 NIW petition. The regulation asks for letters in one form: employer letters that document years of experience. In Dhanasar the AAO relied on "several letters" from aerospace specialists together with records of NASA and Air Force grants. In February 2024 it dismissed two NIW appeals where the letters did not establish national importance or were dated after the filing.

Five sealed cream envelopes fan across an oak desk under a lamp

How many recommendation letters does an NIW petition need?

No number is set. Neither 8 CFR 204.5 nor Matter of Dhanasar counts letters; the AAO asks whether the letters, with the documents behind them, prove each of the three Dhanasar prongs.

The national interest waiver rests on 8 CFR 204.5(k)(4)(ii): "The director may exempt the requirement of a job offer, and thus of a labor certification, for aliens of exceptional ability in the sciences, arts, or business if exemption would be in the national interest." The petitioner submits "evidence to support the claim that such exemption would be in the national interest." The paragraph names no type of evidence and no number of letters.

The test comes from Matter of Dhanasar, 26 I&N Dec. 884 (AAO 2016), decided on December 27, 2016. The petitioner must establish "(1) that the foreign national's proposed endeavor has both substantial merit and national importance; (2) that the foreign national is well positioned to advance the proposed endeavor; and (3) that, on balance, it would be beneficial to the United States to waive the requirements of a job offer and thus of a labor certification." The standard of proof is a preponderance of the evidence.

Dhanasar itself gives no count. The decision describes "several letters from individuals who establish their own expertise in aerospace" and expert letters from people in academia, government and industry, without saying how many there were.

An NIW record with three letters and one with eight face the same two questions. Does the set of letters cover all three prongs, and does each statement in each letter have a document in the record behind it? The guide to the three Dhanasar prongs describes what each prong requires.

Which letters does the regulation require for an EB-2 petition?

Employer letters that prove experience: five years of progressive post-baccalaureate experience on the bachelor's route, or ten years of full-time experience for exceptional ability, each with the writer's name, address and title.

An NIW applicant first qualifies for EB-2. For the advanced degree route through a bachelor's degree, 8 CFR 204.5(k)(3)(i)(B) asks for "an official academic record showing that the alien has a United States baccalaureate degree or a foreign equivalent degree, and evidence in the form of letters from current or former employer(s) showing that the alien has at least five years of progressive post-baccalaureate experience in the specialty."

For exceptional ability the petition must be accompanied by "at least three of the following" six types of evidence. One of them, paragraph (k)(3)(ii)(B), is "Evidence in the form of letter(s) from current or former employer(s) showing that the alien has at least ten years of full-time experience in the occupation for which he or she is being sought." Another, paragraph (k)(3)(ii)(F), is "Evidence of recognition for achievements and significant contributions to the industry or field by peers, governmental entities, or professional or business organizations."

Paragraph 204.5(g)(1) sets the content of experience letters. They come from "current or former employer(s) or trainer(s)" and "shall include the name, address, and title of the writer, and a specific description of the duties performed by the alien or of the training received." If such letters are unavailable, "other documentation relating to the alien's experience or training will be considered."

The number of experience letters follows the work history. Each employer whose years are counted confirms its own period, so five years at two companies take two letters, and five years at one company take one.

What did the letters do in Matter of Dhanasar?

They supported the first two prongs together with documents. Senior figures from academia, government and industry explained the strategic weight of hypersonic propulsion research, and NASA and Air Force funding stood behind the letters on the second prong.

Dhanasar proposed to continue research on hypersonic propulsion systems and to teach. For the first prong the AAO cited "probative expert letters from individuals holding senior positions in academia, government, and industry that describe the importance of hypersonic propulsion research as it relates to U.S. strategic interests." The decision adds that "The letters and the media articles discuss efforts and advances that other countries are currently making" in the field.

For the second prong the AAO relied on "detailed expert letters describing U.S. Government interest and investment in his research." Those letters had documents behind them: the record showed grants for his research from NASA and the Air Force Research Laboratories. The AAO found that he was well positioned to advance the research.

The teaching part of the proposed endeavor went differently. Dhanasar submitted letters "favorably attesting to his teaching abilities at the university level" and evidence of mentoring middle school students. The AAO found that the record did not establish, by a preponderance of the evidence, that his teaching would affect STEM education broadly enough to have national importance, and wrote that "we do not address the remaining prongs in relation to the petitioner's teaching activities."

Both parts of the record contained letters. The research part also contained grant records and press, and the teaching part did not reach the national importance the first prong requires.

Do more letters make an NIW petition stronger?

Only when each letter adds facts that documents confirm. Under Matter of Caron, USCIS may give less weight to an opinion not in accord with other information, and the AAO calls expert letters not presumptive evidence of eligibility.

Matter of Caron International, Inc., 19 I&N Dec. 791 (Comm'r 1988), decided on October 28, 1988, sets the rule for opinion evidence. The agency "may, in its discretion, use as advisory opinions statements from universities, professional organizations, or other sources submitted in evidence as expert testimony." But "where an opinion is not in accord with other information or is in any way questionable, the Service is not required to accept or may give less weight to that evidence."

The AAO decision of February 12, 2024 applied that rule to a record with many letters. The petitioner, a chief executive officer, proposed to manufacture door and trim products and custom cabinetry for residential construction in Florida. He filed "recommendation and support letters" with the petition, then an expert opinion letter and "additional letters of support and recommendation" in response to a request for evidence.

The Acting Director had found that "the letters do not provide specific examples" of the petitioner's influence on the field. The AAO noted that the expert opinion analysed national importance, but it "does not elaborate on how the Petitioner's specific proposed endeavor will have a prospective impact." Citing Caron, the AAO wrote that "the submission of expert opinion letters is not presumptive evidence of eligibility" and found "the advisory opinion is of little probative value." The appeal was dismissed because the record did not establish the national importance of the endeavor.

The AAO decided the appeal on the first prong and did not reach the second and the third.

Which Dhanasar prong should each letter address?

The prong the writer has facts for. The first prong concerns the proposed endeavor, the second the applicant; in February 2024 the AAO treated former employers' praise as second-prong evidence, outside national importance.

Dhanasar lists the factors for the second prong: "the individual's education, skills, knowledge and record of success in related or similar efforts; a model or plan for future activities; any progress towards achieving the proposed endeavor; and the interest of potential customers, users, investors, or other relevant entities or individuals." Each factor points to its own kind of witness.

A professor or a former supervisor can confirm education, skills and a record of success. A company or a laboratory that used the applicant's result can confirm the record of success with dates and figures. A partner, a customer or an investor can confirm progress and interest, and a signed contract or an order behind that letter carries the same facts in documentary form.

The first prong is about the endeavor, and a letter for it explains why the work matters beyond one employer, as the senior figures did for hypersonic propulsion in Dhanasar. In the February 12, 2024 decision the petitioner pointed to "recommendation letters from former employers praising" his qualifications as proof of national importance. The AAO answered that such letters address the second prong, the applicant's position, and not the national importance of the endeavor.

A set of letters can therefore be checked prong by prong. If every letter speaks about the applicant and none about the endeavor, the first prong rests on documents alone, whatever the number of letters.

Do letters dated after the filing count?

The facts in a letter must exist on the filing date. In February 2024 the AAO set aside letters of interest dated after the I-140 filing because they presented a new set of material facts.

Under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(1), "An applicant or petitioner must establish that he or she is eligible for the requested benefit at the time of filing" and must remain eligible through adjudication.

In the AAO decision of February 15, 2024 the petitioner, a sound engineering technician, proposed a music studio and production company in Georgia. The record contained "letters of interest from various individuals or organizations." The AAO noted that they "are dated after the Petitioner filed the Form I-140" and held that "they present a new set of material facts that cannot-and do not-establish eligibility," citing 8 CFR 103.2(b)(1) and the precedents Matter of Katigbak and Matter of Izummi.

Without those letters the record did not show the interest of potential customers or other parties that the second prong looks for. The AAO also found the first prong unmet, withdrew the Director's conclusion that a bachelor's degree alone qualified the petitioner as an advanced degree professional, and dismissed the appeal.

A request for evidence gives time for new letters, and under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(8)(iv) "in no case shall the maximum response period provided in a request for evidence exceed twelve weeks." A letter written in that period describes contracts, results and interest that existed when the petition was filed, with the dates of those facts.

Should NIW letters come from independent experts or from colleagues?

The rules allow both. USCIS weighs the writer's relationship with the applicant, and the EB-1A chapter of the Policy Manual expects recognition beyond the applicant's personal and professional acquaintances.

The NIW provisions of 8 CFR 204.5 do not divide writers into kinds. The guidance on letters is most detailed in the USCIS Policy Manual chapter on EB-1A extraordinary ability: "The relationship or affiliation between the beneficiary and the witness is also a factor the officer should consider when evaluating the significance of witnesses' statements."

The same chapter states that a person with sustained acclaim "would have received recognition for their accomplishments well beyond the circle of their personal and professional acquaintances." That sentence concerns EB-1A, where the standard is the very top of the field under 8 CFR 204.5(h)(2). For an NIW record it describes what letters from people outside the applicant's employer add: a view of the work from the field.

A colleague who worked with the applicant knows the facts of the work. A specialist outside the employer can say how the field uses the result. In Dhanasar the writers were "individuals who establish their own expertise in aerospace," and the Policy Manual asks letters to "set forth the basis of the writer's knowledge and expertise."

Where to find writers outside the employer is covered in the article on finding an independent expert for an NIW letter, and who may sign in the article on who can write an expert opinion letter.

Can a letter replace a document in an NIW petition?

No. The EB-1A chapter of the Policy Manual says statements in letters of support "should be corroborated by documentary evidence in the record," and in Dhanasar the funding records stood behind the expert letters on the second prong.

The Policy Manual chapter on EB-1A sets out the place of letters in a record. Letters of support, "while not without weight," should not be the foundation of a successful claim in that classification. "Rather, the statements made by the witnesses should be corroborated by documentary evidence in the record."

It also describes the letters that carry little weight: "Letters that merely reiterate USCIS' definitions relating to this classification or make general and expansive statements regarding the beneficiary and the beneficiary's accomplishments are generally not persuasive." And: "These letters should be considered, but do not necessarily show the beneficiary's claimed extraordinary ability."

In an NIW record the same pairing works prong by prong. A letter that says the applicant's method cut costs for a hospital network is paired with the contract, the internal report or the publication with the figures. A letter that reports investor interest is paired with the term sheet or the funding agreement dated before filing.

Before filing, each statement of fact in a letter can be marked with the exhibit number of the document that confirms it. A statement with no exhibit is either supported by a new document or removed by the writer.

What does a letter in another language need?

A full English translation certified as complete and accurate, with the translator's certification of competence, under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(3). A legible photocopy of the signed letter is acceptable for initial filing.

Under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(3), "Any document containing foreign language submitted to USCIS shall be accompanied by a full English language translation which the translator has certified as complete and accurate, and by the translator's certification that he or she is competent to translate from the foreign language into English." A letter from a professor in Germany or a client in Brazil written in the local language goes in with both the original and the certified translation.

Under 8 CFR 204.5(g)(1), "ordinary legible photocopies" of supporting documents are acceptable for initial filing and approval, and "at the discretion of the director, original documents may be required in individual cases."

Each translated letter counts once in the record, as one writer's statement. A translation does not add a second piece of evidence, and an English version signed separately by the same writer repeats the same testimony.

How does IAE prepare an expert opinion letter for an NIW petition?

An expert from the public IAE registry in the applicant's field checks and signs a letter of up to 15 pages with an analysis under the three Dhanasar prongs. The standard turnaround is 10 business days, 5 on rush.

Send the applicant's CV and the petition category through the expert opinion letters page. The secretariat confirms the expert, the fee and the turnaround within one business day, and the fee depends on the category and the volume of materials. For EB-2 NIW the letter analyses the three prongs of Matter of Dhanasar, including the balance of interests in favor of waiving labor certification. The expert's CV and declaration of independence are attached.

The work runs in three steps. On the first day the secretariat receives the CV, a description of the achievements and the draft petition and asks for anything missing. On the second day an expert from the registry in the subject area is selected, and you approve the candidate and the CV. In up to 8 business days the secretariat prepares the draft from your documents, the expert checks it, makes changes and signs, and the applicant and the attorney make factual corrections, with one round included.

Under the IAE Impartiality Policy (IAE-GOV-002), the expert checks every statement in the draft, corrects or removes anything the expert does not consider supported, and signs only a text that states the expert's own professional opinion. Before the order is assigned the expert confirms in writing that he or she has no personal, financial or professional relationship with the applicant, the client's attorney or the client's employer. One expert signs one letter for one petition, and a package of several letters is signed by experts from different organizations.

The standard turnaround is 10 business days and the rush option 5, counted from payment and receipt of all materials. The expert's status can be checked in the public IAE registry by QR code and Member ID. IAE is not a law firm, and neither IAE nor the expert influences the decision: USCIS weighs the letter with the rest of the record.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert opinion letters

Ready to strengthen your petition with an expert opinion letter?

Send the applicant's CV and the petition category: the expert, cost and timeline within one business day.

Quote request

Received

Expert, cost and timeline within one business day

CategoryEB‑1A
ExpertIn the applicant's field
Timeline10 business days