Expert witnesses
Manufacturing defect vs design defect: what does each expert have to show?
A manufacturing defect is a flaw in one unit that left the factory different from its own design. A design defect sits in the design itself, so every unit of the model carries it. The two theories need different experts and different evidence: a materials engineer who compares the failed part with the specifications, or a design engineer who proves a feasible safer alternative.

What is the difference between a manufacturing defect and a design defect?
A manufacturing defect means the unit departs from the manufacturer's intended design. A design defect means the intended design is itself unreasonably dangerous, judged by consumer expectations or by weighing risks against benefits.
Florida's standard jury instructions put the two definitions side by side in instruction 403.7, approved by the Supreme Court of Florida on March 26, 2015 in its opinion on Report No. 13-01 (Products Liability). Under the manufacturing part of instruction 403.7, a product is unreasonably dangerous because of a manufacturing defect if it is different from the design the manufacturer intended and does not perform as safely as the intended design would have performed.
For design the instruction offers bracketed alternatives: a product is unreasonably dangerous because of its design if "the product fails to perform as safely as an ordinary consumer would expect when used as intended or when used in a manner reasonably foreseeable by the manufacturer" and, or, "the risk of danger in the design outweighs the benefits." The committee notes say the committee takes no position on whether the two tests are given alternatively or together.
Texas states the same split in case law. The Fifth Circuit, applying Texas law in Casey v. Toyota Motor Engineering & Manufacturing North America, Inc. (October 20, 2014), quoted the Supreme Court of Texas: "a manufacturing defect exists when a product deviates, in its construction or quality, from the specifications or planned output in a manner that renders it unreasonably dangerous." A design claim in Texas needs a safer alternative design that existed when the product left the manufacturer.
The practical test is simple to state. If the claimant says the product that hurt him was bad because the factory made a mistake, the theory is manufacturing. If the claimant says every product of that model is dangerous because of how it was designed, the theory is design.
What does a manufacturing defect expert have to show?
A specific deviation: how the failed unit differs from the manufacturer's specifications or from identical units, that the deviation existed when the product left the manufacturer, and that it caused the harm, with other causes ruled out.
Ohio wrote the test into its code. Under section 2307.74 of the Ohio Revised Code, a product is defective in manufacture or construction if, when it left the control of its manufacturer, "it deviated in a material way from the design specifications, formula, or performance standards of the manufacturer, or from otherwise identical units manufactured to the same design specifications, formula, or performance standards." The same section adds that the product may be defective "even though its manufacturer exercised all possible care in its manufacture or construction."
The expert therefore needs a reference point. It may be the drawing and the specification for the part, the alloy or formula the manufacturer called for, the tolerances in the quality plan, or sound units from the same production run. The expert examines the failed unit against that reference: a weld with lack of fusion where the drawing calls for full penetration, a casting with porosity outside the acceptance criteria, a heat treatment that left the steel softer than specified.
Texas adds requirements of its own. In Casey the Fifth Circuit quoted Ford Motor Co. v. Ledesma (Tex. 2007): "a specific defect must be identified by competent evidence and other possible causes must be ruled out," and "the deviation from design that caused the injury must be identified." The plaintiff must also prove "that the product was defective when it left the hands of the manufacturer," which puts wear, repairs and later damage on the expert's list of causes to exclude.
Because the claim concerns one unit, the expert's work centers on that unit and its production history: lot numbers, inspection records, supplier certificates, returns and complaints for the same lot. If the part has to be sectioned or tested to destruction, the other side's experts lose the chance to examine it in its original state.
Is a product failure enough to prove a manufacturing defect?
Not in Texas. In Casey v. Toyota the Fifth Circuit held that an airbag that deflated too early showed a product failure, not a manufacturing defect, because no deviation from Toyota's specifications was identified.
Dawna Casey died after her 2010 Toyota Highlander left the road at high speed, flipped and rolled. She was partially ejected through the side window. Her family alleged that the side curtain airbag failed to stay inflated long enough. The airbag was designed to stay inflated for about six seconds and deflated in about two.
The Fifth Circuit quoted Ledesma: "Texas law does not generally recognize a product failure or malfunction, standing alone, as sufficient proof of a product defect." The court treated the six-second figure as a performance standard, not a specification, and noted that the family showed no difference between this airbag and other Highlander airbags. With no specific defect identified and no evidence of how the airbag departed from Toyota's specifications, the manufacturing claim failed. The court affirmed judgment as a matter of law for Toyota.
Ohio's statute reads differently on one point. Section 2307.74 counts a material deviation from the manufacturer's "performance standards" as a manufacturing defect, next to design specifications and formula. Under the Ohio text, proof that a unit fell short of the maker's own performance standard is a recognized route; the expert still has to tie the shortfall to that unit and to the time it left the manufacturer's control.
Either way, the expert who says only that the product broke has not done the work. The report has to name what in this unit was different and how the expert knows it was different before the product left the factory.
What does a design defect expert have to show?
That the design itself is unreasonably dangerous. In Texas that means a safer alternative design that would have prevented or significantly reduced the risk, without substantially impairing utility, and was economically and technologically feasible at the time.
The Fifth Circuit listed the Texas elements in Casey: "(1) the product was defectively designed so as to render it unreasonably dangerous; (2) a safer alternative design existed; and (3) the defect was a producing cause of the injury for which the plaintiff seeks recovery." Section 82.005 of the Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code defines a safer alternative design as "a product design other than the one actually used that in reasonable probability" would have prevented or significantly reduced the risk of the claimant's personal injury "without substantially impairing the product's utility" and "was economically and technologically feasible at the time the product left the control of the manufacturer."
The same opinion quoted earlier Fifth Circuit law on risk and utility: "the plaintiff must show the safety benefits from [the] proposed design are foreseeably greater than the resulting costs." Florida's instruction offers the consumer expectations test and the risk-benefit test in brackets, to be given alone or together.
A design expert works with the whole model, not one unit. The evidence is the design file, the drawings and design reviews, test reports, the manufacturer's choices between options, competitors' designs on the market at the time, patents, standards and the cost of the alternative. The failed unit matters mainly to show that it was built as designed, which is the opposite of what a manufacturing expert tries to show.
Why did the design claim in Casey v. Toyota fail as well?
The family's expert had not tested his alternative airbag design, had not done a risk-utility analysis, offered only conclusions on feasibility and gave no cost estimate. The court held that this was not evidence of a safer alternative.
The family relied on an engineer named Renfroe and a patent application for an alternative airbag. On whether the alternative would have prevented or reduced the injury, the court found that Renfroe ran no tests and that the tests in the patent did not reproduce the forces of this rollover. The court wrote that "Texas law expects that an alternative design be tested before a jury can reasonably conclude" that it would reduce the risk of injury.
On utility, Renfroe had not performed a risk-utility analysis, so there was no evidence that the alternative's safety benefits outweighed its costs. On technological feasibility, the design had never been installed in a vehicle, and the court said that "Renfroe's unsupported assertion would not be enough" to show that it could have been. On economic feasibility, no estimate of the cost of incorporating the design was offered, and statements that the material was cost-effective or commercially available did not fill the gap.
Each of those four points is a task for the design expert before the report is served: build or obtain the alternative, test it under the conditions of the accident, compare benefits with costs, and document that the alternative could have been made and paid for when the product left the factory.
What if the product was destroyed and the defect cannot be identified?
Some states allow circumstantial proof. Ohio's code accepts circumstantial or other competent evidence when direct evidence is unavailable, while Texas generally requires a specific defect to be identified.
Section 2307.73(B) of the Ohio Revised Code covers the claimant who is unable, "because the manufacturer's product in question was destroyed" or for another reason, to establish the defect by direct evidence. In that case "it shall be sufficient for the claimant to present circumstantial or other competent evidence" that establishes by a preponderance of the evidence that the product was defective in one of the ways the code lists. The burden stays the same; only the kind of evidence changes.
Texas is stricter. In Ford Motor Co. v. Ridgway (2004), a case about a pickup that burst into flame, Justice Hecht wrote a concurring opinion joined by Justice Owen. He agreed that "Few would question the use of circumstantial evidence to prove products liability in appropriate cases," and added that "[t]he hard issue is not whether it can be done, but when and how." An inference of liability, he wrote, "is really two inferences: that the product was defective, and that the defect existed at the time of sale."
The concurrence noted that fires in pickups occur for all sorts of reasons. When the product is gone, the expert who relies on circumstantial proof has to exclude the other causes the evidence leaves open: misuse, poor maintenance, repairs, aftermarket parts, an outside ignition source. In Texas, the Ledesma rule quoted in Casey means that this exclusion work rarely substitutes for identifying the deviation itself.
Can a case plead both theories, and does one expert cover both?
A complaint often pleads both, as the family did in Casey. The proof rarely comes from one expert: a materials or failure analysis engineer for the unit, a design engineer from the product's industry for the model.
The Casey family pleaded manufacturing and design defects against Toyota, and both claims went to judgment together. They failed for different reasons: the manufacturing claim because no deviation from Toyota's specifications was identified, the design claim because the alternative was neither tested nor costed. One expert's work did not cure the other gap.
The two theories can also pull against each other. A manufacturing expert argues that the unit was not built as designed. A design expert argues that the design, faithfully built, was dangerous. When both are pleaded, the experts coordinate on the facts of the unit so that one report does not undercut the other.
The product liability expert witness page sorts specialists by the defect theory. Its Part failure group names metallurgists and materials engineers on cracks, welds, heat treatment and alloy composition, and electrical engineers on wiring and electronics failures, with comparison against drawings and sound units. Its Design group names engineers from the product's industry, who address which other designs were available when the product left the manufacturer.
Which documents does each expert ask for first?
The manufacturing expert asks for the failed unit, exemplars, drawings, specifications and production records for the lot. The design expert asks for the design file, test reports, alternatives considered and market designs at the time of sale.
For a manufacturing claim the request list starts with the unit itself and its chain of custody, then the drawing and specification revision in force on the production date, inspection and test records for the lot, supplier material certificates, the corrective action file, warranty returns for the same lot and exemplar units from the same run. Ohio's definition makes "otherwise identical units" a lawful comparison, so the exemplars are evidence, not background.
For a design claim the list moves up a level: design requirements and design reviews, failure mode and effects analyses, validation tests, field data for the model, documents on alternatives the manufacturer considered and rejected, competitors' products, patents and standards in force when the product left the manufacturer, and cost data. The Casey opinion turned on testing, risk-utility analysis, feasibility and cost, and each needs documents of its own.
In federal court the expert's report lists the facts or data considered, and the opposing lawyer reads that list against these categories. A manufacturing report with no specification in its materials, or a design report with no cost figure, is the first thing a motion to exclude will point to.
How does IAE find a manufacturing or design defect expert?
In the request choose the case type Product liability and name the product, the failed part and the defect theory. Within 5 business days IAE sends 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates and lists of prior testimony.
The product liability page lists 8 specialties, among them failure analysis, materials science, electrical engineering, product design and vehicle crashworthiness. IAE chooses the specialty by the defect theory the firm needs to prove, so the description in the request matters: manufacture or design, the product and model, the failed part, where it is held now and whether it has been tested.
The request form asks for the field, the case type, the state and court, the firm's side, the expert disclosure deadline and the parties with their counsel. The form asks not to include privileged or sealed information. Within 1 business day IAE replies whether it can search in that field by the deadline. Each candidate confirms in writing that he or she has no ties to the parties or their counsel.
Within 5 business days the firm receives 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates, testimony in the last 4 years and publications in the last 10 years. Candidate names and CVs come after the $2,000 search fee is paid in advance. If no candidate fits, the second search is free, and if IAE finds no candidates, it refunds the fee. The expert's hourly rate never depends on the outcome of the case or on the content of testimony. IAE is not a law firm; case strategy and the decision to retain an expert stay with the attorney.
Sources
- In re Standard Jury Instructions in Civil Cases, Report No. 13-01 (Products Liability), No. SC13-683 (Fla. Mar. 26, 2015), instruction 403.7 (FSU College of Law, Florida Supreme Court dockets)
- Casey v. Toyota Motor Engineering & Manufacturing North America, Inc., No. 13-11119 (5th Cir. Oct. 20, 2014)
- Ohio Revised Code 2307.74, Product defective in manufacture or construction
- Ohio Revised Code 2307.73, Liability of manufacturer
- Ford Motor Co. v. Ridgway, No. 02-0552 (Tex. Feb. 6, 2004), concurring opinion of Justice Hecht (Hall Approved)
Read also
All articles
State of the art defense in product liability: what must the manufacturer's expert prove about the technology available when the product was made?
The state of the art defense asks what a manufacturer could have known and built on the day the product left its hands, not on the day of the injury
Toy injury expert witness: small parts, age grading and ASTM F963 in a children's product case
A toy injury case usually turns on a short list of questions: was the toy meant for a child under three, did any part fit inside the federal small
Machine guarding expert witness: what does the engineer examine when a worker is hurt by an unguarded machine?
When a worker is hurt at the point of operation of a machine, the case usually turns on the guard: how the machine was designed to keep hands outExpert witnesses
Need an expert witness for your case?
Describe the question, the case type and the court. Within 5 business days you receive 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates and lists of prior testimony.

