Journal
Do you need publications or citations for an NIW?
Neither 8 CFR 204.5(k) nor the USCIS Policy Manual makes publications or citations a requirement for an EB-2 national interest waiver. The Policy Manual lists a strong citation history among the evidence for the second Dhanasar prong and says the list is not a checklist. In AAO decisions of 2022 and 2023, citations carried weight when they recorded interest in the applicant's work from others in the field; a bare count fell short.

Are publications or citations required for an EB-2 NIW?
No. The regulation sets EB-2 eligibility through an advanced degree or exceptional ability and lets USCIS waive the job offer in the national interest. Neither part names publications or citations.
Under 8 CFR 204.5(k)(2), an advanced degree is "any United States academic or professional degree or a foreign equivalent degree above that of baccalaureate." A U.S. bachelor's degree or a foreign equivalent followed by at least five years of progressive experience in the specialty is treated as a master's degree. If the specialty customarily requires a doctorate, the applicant needs a U.S. doctorate or a foreign equivalent. Exceptional ability is "a degree of expertise significantly above that ordinarily encountered in the sciences, arts, or business."
For exceptional ability, paragraph (k)(3)(ii) asks for at least three of six kinds of evidence: an academic record in the area, letters from employers about at least ten years of full-time experience, a license or certification, a salary or other pay for services at the level of exceptional ability, membership in professional associations, and recognition for achievements and significant contributions by peers, government bodies or professional or business organizations. None of the six mentions articles or citations.
Paragraph (k)(4)(ii) opens with the waiver rule: "The director may exempt the requirement of a job offer, and thus of a labor certification, for aliens of exceptional ability in the sciences, arts, or business if exemption would be in the national interest." USCIS tests the national interest under Matter of Dhanasar, an AAO precedent of 2016. Its three prongs are set out in the guide Matter of Dhanasar: the three NIW prongs and the evidence for each.
The EB-1A rule reads differently. Item (vi) of the ten criteria in 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3) is "Evidence of the alien's authorship of scholarly articles in the field, in professional or major trade publications or other major media." An EB-1A applicant without a major international award must meet at least three of the ten, and authorship can be one of them. Paragraph (k) has no such item.
Where do publications and citations appear in the Policy Manual?
In the list of evidence for the second Dhanasar prong, which asks whether the applicant is well positioned to advance the proposed endeavor. The list names a strong citation history and published articles about the applicant's work.
The USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 5 separates the first two prongs in one sentence: "Unlike the first prong, which focuses on the merit and importance of the proposed endeavor, the second prong centers on the person." Before its list of evidence for the second prong the chapter states: "This list is not meant to be a checklist or to indicate that any one type of evidence is either required or sufficient to establish eligibility."
Three items on that list concern published work. The first is "Published articles or media reports about the person's achievements or current work." The second covers "a strong citation history of the person's work or excerpts of published articles showing positive discourse around, or adoption of, the person's work." The third is "Evidence that the person's work has influenced the field of endeavor." All three concern what other people wrote about the work or how the field used it. Authorship by the applicant is not a separate item.
Research without an economic return may qualify under the first prong. The chapter quotes Dhanasar: "endeavors related to research, pure science, and the furtherance of human knowledge may qualify, whether or not the potential accomplishments in those fields are likely to translate into economic benefits for the United States."
For the second prong, USCIS considers an advanced degree, particularly a Ph.D., in a STEM field tied to the proposed endeavor and related to work furthering a critical and emerging technology or other STEM area important to U.S. competitiveness or national security "an especially positive factor." The next sentence of the chapter reads: "A degree in and of itself, however, is not a basis to determine that a person is well positioned to advance the proposed endeavor."
Did Dhanasar's own case turn on citations?
No. In a 2022 decision the AAO wrote that its second-prong finding for Dhanasar "was not based on his citation record." The Policy Manual names his role in research projects funded by NASA and the Air Force.
Footnote 71 of Chapter 5 sums up the record in Dhanasar. The AAO "favorably considered documentation" of his part in projects funded by grants from the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) and the Air Force Research Laboratories (AFRL) within the U.S. Department of Defense. The significance of his research "was corroborated by evidence of peer and government interest in his research, as well as by consistent government funding of the petitioner's research projects." His proposed endeavor was hypersonic technology research.
The AAO came back to that record on August 31, 2022, in a decision on motions filed by a researcher in electrical engineering (In Re: 19405546). It wrote that the precedent decision had listed Dhanasar's publications and other published materials citing his work, but that the finding that he was well positioned "was not based on his citation record." Both motions, to reopen and to reconsider, were dismissed.
How does the AAO weigh a citation record in an NIW case?
As evidence of interest from others in the field. In 2022 and 2023 decisions the AAO checked whether citations were documented, whether the cited research related to the proposed endeavor and how the count compared with the field.
On February 2, 2023 the AAO dismissed the appeal of an environmental scientist (In Re: 23070928). She held a master's degree in natural resources engineering, awarded in 2013 by a university in Iran, and proposed research on urban water management and green infrastructure. A Google Scholar printout showed 17 citations of her work, and a 2019 "mini-review" article cited five of her articles.
Most of those citations concerned another subject. In the AAO's words, "Nearly all the documented citations of the Petitioner's work relate to this earlier research rather than to her more recent work," and the earlier research included studies of agricultural pesticide runoff. The letters in the file did not explain how that earlier work related to the proposed endeavor. The AAO quoted the precedent's phrase "the degree of interest that the individual's work has attracted" and concluded: "Here, the limited evidence of interest is insufficient to meet the Petitioner's burden."
The same decision states a general rule: "The national interest waiver is an additional benefit, not provided to every member of the professions holding an advanced degree who applies, and not every productive researcher will qualify for that additional benefit."
On May 11, 2023 the AAO sustained the appeal of a biochemist with a Ph.D. who worked as a postdoctoral associate (In Re: 26762198). His record contained "multiple published journal papers co-authored by the Petitioner; citation records for his journal papers" and research papers, scientific books and databases that referenced his work. According to the AAO, independent letters from experts in biochemistry, supported by other evidence in the record, indicated that his work "has been highly cited and utilized by other researchers." The AAO withdrew the Director's decision and found him eligible for the waiver.
Which citation evidence did the AAO give little weight?
A self-compiled citation index, citing articles that did not set the researcher's work apart from the other papers they referenced, and a count without statistics for the field. All three came up in the August 2022 decision.
In that case the researcher had filed his CV, academic credentials, published articles, conference presentations, peer review activity and articles that cited his work. With the motion he added "a self-compiled citation index for his three highest cited articles" and argued that most citations of those articles came from "independent researchers who had not previously worked with the Petitioner." He offered no evidence to corroborate the index, and the AAO wrote that the self-compiled information "lacks probative value."
The citing articles drew a separate objection. In its earlier decision in the same case, the AAO had found that they did not set his work apart from the various other papers each of them referenced.
A benchmark was missing as well: "Moreover, the record does not include comparative statistics indicating how often other engineering researchers are cited." Footnote 3 of the decision names what the file lacked, such as copies of the citing articles or "citation results from databases or search engines (such as Scopus, Web of Science, or Google Scholar)." The AAO also said what citations prove. They "corroborate that he has disseminated his findings," but in its view they did not establish that his work had influenced engineering researchers or formed a record of success that left him well positioned to advance his proposed research.
How do applicants without publications prove the second prong?
With other items from the same Policy Manual list: degrees, patents, expert letters, a plan for the work, letters from customers, investment, contracts, letters from government agencies, grants and evidence that others use the work.
The list in Chapter 5 includes "Correspondence from prospective or potential employers, clients, or customers" and "Copies of contracts, agreements, or licenses showing the potential impact of the proposed endeavor." It also names evidence that the applicant "has received investment from U.S. investors, such as venture capital firms, angel investors, or start-up accelerators, and that the amounts are appropriate to the relevant endeavor." Under evidence of how others use the work, the chapter lists contracts with companies using products the applicant developed, documents on technology the applicant invented and patents or licenses for the applicant's innovations.
Entrepreneurs get a sentence of their own: "While entrepreneurs typically do not undergo the same type of peer review common in academia, entrepreneurs may operate in a variety of high-tech or cutting-edge industries that have their own industry or technology experts that provide various forms of peer review." Officers may also treat admission into an incubator or accelerator "as an endorsement of the petitioner's proposed plan or past track record, and the petitioner being well positioned to advance the endeavor."
Press coverage is a separate kind of evidence. In the paragraph on published materials the chapter lists "printed or online newspaper or magazine articles or other similar published materials" about the applicant or the applicant's company, "with some reference to the petitioner's role," that record significant attention or recognition by the media. The applicant may add evidence of the outlet's reputation.
Government support is on the list too: awards, grants or other non-monetary support, such as free use of facilities, from federal, state or local government entities with expertise in economic development, research and development, or job creation.
Can reviewing other people's manuscripts replace your own articles?
Not on the applicant's word. In an April 2024 decision the AAO noted that the applicant had reviewed manuscripts as a first-year graduate student, before his first article, and wrote that his claim needed evidence.
The applicant in the decision of April 4, 2024 (In Re: 30646279) researched wireless communication, cyber security and AI tools for health care. He claimed that only highly esteemed researchers are invited to evaluate the work of their peers. The AAO answered: "The burden is on the Petitioner to submit evidence to support this claim." The record showed that he had served as a peer reviewer "as early as June 2010 when he was a first-year graduate student," and "At that time, he had not yet published any articles of his own."
Review work at that early stage, the AAO wrote, did not appear consistent with his claim. The AAO withdrew the Director's decision and remanded the case for a new decision, because the denial did not identify specific deficiencies in the record.
An editorial post faced the same test in the February 2023 decision. The environmental scientist sat on the editorial board of a journal of MedWin Publishers. The AAO wrote that "The journal publisher's own materials are inherently self-serving and promotional with respect to the publisher's reputation and asserted standards," and noted that the publisher's letter did not explain how a scientist with a background in civil engineering was qualified to edit a journal of medical science.
Does the journal or the publication date matter?
The NIW list in the Policy Manual says nothing about journal rank, while the EB-1A chapter weighs articles in highly ranked journals. On timing, 8 CFR 103.2(b)(1) measures eligibility at the time of filing.
The second-prong list in Chapter 5 names published articles about the work, citation history and influence on the field. It gives no ranking of journals and no minimum number of citations. The EB-1A chapter, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 2, does weigh rank. Among the examples for its final merits determination are articles in "particularly highly-ranked journals" relative to other journals in the field, for instance by impact factor, and a total rate of citations high relative to others in the field, "such as the person has a high h-index for the field."
The date rule is in 8 CFR 103.2(b)(1): "An applicant or petitioner must establish that he or she is eligible for the requested benefit at the time of filing the benefit request and must continue to be eligible through adjudication." An article published after the I-140 is filed, and the citations it collects later, come after the date on which that rule measures eligibility. An applicant who wants an article in the file therefore counts the journal's review time back from the planned filing date.
What does IAE Review offer an author?
Double-anonymous review by at least two independent reviewers, an initial decision within 7 business days, a decision after review within 60 calendar days, and open access under CC BY 4.0 with no article-processing charge.
IAE Review is the peer-reviewed open-access journal of the International Association of Experts. It is interdisciplinary and has eight sections: the six OECD fields of science, Expert examination and assessment, and Professional practice and standards. IAE membership is not required and does not affect the editorial decision.
Manuscripts are accepted in English or Russian as DOCX, PDF or LaTeX files. Length depends on the type of publication: 800 to 15,000 words excluding references, and 5,000 to 12,000 words for an original research article. The abstract and 5 to 8 keywords are given in both languages. Names, affiliations and self-citations are removed from the main text; author details, funding and conflicts of interest go on a separate title page. A preprint is accepted if the cover letter discloses it, and a manuscript based on a conference paper must contain at least 30% new material.
The editors make an initial check within 7 business days and screen the manuscript for plagiarism and AI use. At least two independent reviewers, in-house or invited, then assess the anonymised text, with a target of 21 business days. The decision is one of four: accept, accept with revisions, revise or reject. It comes within 60 calendar days of submission, and revisions requested by reviewers extend the term.
Articles appear as soon as they are ready, without fixed issues. Each has a permanent page and PDFs in English and Russian, and the English version is the Version of Record. Authors keep copyright and grant IAE a non-exclusive licence.
If an applicant files an IAE Review article with a petition, the article is one exhibit among the others, and USCIS decides the petition. Manuscripts go through the submission form.
Sources
- USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 5, Advanced Degree or Exceptional Ability
- USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 2, Extraordinary Ability
- 8 CFR 204.5, Petitions for employment-based immigrants (eCFR)
- 8 CFR 103.2, Submission and adjudication of benefit requests (eCFR)
- AAO non-precedent decision, In Re: 19405546 (August 31, 2022)
- AAO non-precedent decision, In Re: 23070928 (February 2, 2023)
- AAO non-precedent decision, In Re: 26762198 (May 11, 2023)
- AAO non-precedent decision, In Re: 30646279 (April 4, 2024)
Read also
All articles
How long does peer review take, and what decides the wait?
Authors who reported 3,500 review experiences to the SciRev site waited 13 weeks on average for the first decision, and accepted papers spent 17
Can you submit a paper to two journals at the same time?
In most fields the answer is no. The ICMJE Recommendations state that authors should not submit the same manuscript, in the same or different
Can you publish a research paper without a university affiliation?
A university affiliation is not a condition of authorship. The ICMJE Recommendations define an author by four criteria of contributionJournal
Want to publish in IAE Review?
Submit your manuscript in Russian or English as DOCX, PDF or LaTeX through the submission form. Initial decision within 7 business days.

