Expert report review
Review of an altered document examination report: what does a reviewer check when a page is said to be substituted?
An opinion that a page was substituted rests on differences between the pages of one document: fonts, margins, printing process, paper and fastening marks. A reviewer checks what the examiner compared, on which item, and whether ordinary preparation explains the difference. In Ceglia v. Zuckerberg a federal magistrate judge weighed examiners from both sides on a two-page contract, and his 2013 report records how each opinion fared.

What must a substituted-page opinion establish?
That one page differs from the others in features that normal preparation does not explain, which examinations found the difference, and what limits applied. A difference alone is an observation, not a conclusion of substitution.
The SWGDOC Standard for Examination of Altered Documents, version 2013-1, lists features an examiner looks for. Among them are "Use of different fonts, sizes, and/or styles" (7.3.5), "Uneven margins" (7.3.9), "Different printing processes" (7.3.10), differences in fastening and binding marks (7.3.12) and "Variations in paper characteristics" (7.3.15). Step 7.11 then requires the examiner to "Analyze, compare, and evaluate the findings."
The same standard puts limits first. Section 5.1 says items "may have inherent limitations that can interfere with the procedures in this standard" and that "Limitations should be noted and recorded." Under 5.2 they can be due to non-original documents or limited comparability.
Section 7.1 requires that "Examinations performed, relevant observations, and results shall be documented," and 7.2 requires the reasons to be documented when the examiner stops a procedure early. Under 8.1 conclusions "may be reached once sufficient examinations have been conducted." A reviewer reads the report for three things in order: the observed difference, the examination that found it, and the reasoning that turns the difference into a finding that a page was replaced.
Did the examiner compare the pages with a known version of the document?
The SWGDOC standard separates examinations of questioned and known items from examinations of questioned items alone. A second version of the contract, a draft or a counterpart changes what a page-to-page comparison can support.
Section 1.2 of the SWGDOC standard says the work depends on "whether the examination(s) are of questioned and known items, exclusively questioned items, or a single item." A report on one two-page contract with nothing to compare it with stands on internal differences only.
In Ceglia v. Zuckerberg, No. 10-CV-569A(F) (W.D.N.Y.), the plaintiff sued on a "Work for Hire Document" said to have been signed with Mark Zuckerberg on April 28, 2003. The defendants' digital forensics firm, Stroz Friedberg, recovered a different contract, the StreetFax Document. It found that "the second page of the StreetFax Document is virtually identical to the second page of the Work for Hire Document, but the first pages of both documents are different."
The defendants' theory was that the plaintiff "created the Work for Hire Document by amending the text of page 1 of the StreetFax Document." With a known version in hand, the dispute moved off the question whether page 1 looked different and onto the question which version was authentic. A reviewer asks the same question of any report: what known material existed, whether the examiner asked for it, and whether the report says why it was not used.
Does a printer difference between pages prove that a page was swapped?
Not by itself. It proves that the pages were printed differently. The report must explain why the difference points to substitution rather than to two print runs during normal preparation of the same document.
In Ceglia the defendants' typeface and print technology expert, Romano, concluded that "pages 1 and 2 of the Work for Hire Document were printed on different printers," and stated this "with the highest degree of certainty possible." The report describes them as "two different laser printers," with page 1 printed on the more recent machine.
A reviewer reads such a finding against the 2023 committee note to Rule 702: "Forensic experts should avoid assertions of absolute or one hundred percent certainty" when the method is subjective and thus potentially subject to error. The note was written ten years after the Ceglia report, and today the wording of a certainty claim is a point for the reviewer.
The reviewer then lists the explanations the report considered and rejected, for example a page reprinted on another printer during preparation of the same document. SWGDOC section 7.3.10 treats a different printing process as a feature to observe; it does not equate it with substitution.
What does a toner or paper match between pages show?
That the test used could not tell the materials apart, and nothing about when the pages were made. In Ceglia the magistrate judge noted that identical printer, toner and paper would fit the theory that both pages were forged.
The plaintiff's expert Stewart compared the toner on the two pages by thin-layer chromatography. The report quotes him: "they matched at the level of analysis of TLC," and he conceded that this "is not a very strong conclusion."
The magistrate judge went further. If both pages had been "printed by the same printer using the same toner and paper," that "conclusion nevertheless would be consistent with Defendants' assertion" that both pages were recent forgeries. A finding of sameness answered the page 1 substitution theory but not the claim that the whole document was made later.
Laboratories word such findings at class level. The New York report standardization project phrases a positive paper finding as "Could have originated from a common source or another source with similar characteristics to those examined," and a positive ink finding as "showed no differences in the inks examined." A reviewer checks that the report does not convert such wording into a statement that the pages are original.
Was the paper test run on the questioned document itself?
The reviewer matches every test result to the item that was sampled. In Ceglia the plaintiff's paper expert had analyzed samples from a different document, so his finding said nothing about the contract pages.
The plaintiff's paper expert, Rantanen, found the paper "consistent with coming from the same mill and production run." At deposition he agreed it was "also not factually impossible" that the samples came from different mills or runs. The magistrate judge, citing an earlier decision of November 20, 2012, noted that Rantanen had "analyzed paper samples from Specifications Document rather than the Work for Hire Document." His supplemental report was found as equivocal as the first.
Thickness measurements split differently. LaPorte, an expert for the defendants, measured the pages and concluded only that the paper "may have originated from a different source." Another defense examiner, Tytell, said the difference was "not enough to definitely say that the two pages were of a different caliper." The magistrate judge found the two positions reconcilable.
The reviewer builds a table: test, item and page sampled, date, instrument, result, and the wording of the conclusion. A result that cannot be tied to the questioned page is dropped from the analysis, and a conclusion stronger than its own result is marked.
What do matching staple holes prove?
That the pages were stapled together at least once in the same position. They do not prove a single stapling or the absence of substitution. In Ceglia the magistrate judge called the staple-hole argument a red herring.
The plaintiff's examiner Blanco relied on matching staple holes on the two pages to argue that the document had been stapled once. A defense expert, Lyter, answered that "a single set of staple holes does not mean that a document was stapled only once."
The magistrate judge held that Blanco's staple-hole theory "is not probative of anything relevant to the authenticity of the Work for Hire Document but, rather, is a red herring." Matching holes did not exclude that both pages were recent forgeries stapled together.
SWGDOC lists differences in fastening and binding marks as a sign of alteration (7.3.12). A difference points to a separate fastening history. Lyter's point applies to a match as well: a replacement page can be stapled through holes that already exist. The reviewer checks whether the report says which of the two it found and how it measured the positions.
Does each opinion answer the theory the other side actually advances?
Not always. In Ceglia much of the plaintiff's examiners' work rebutted a page 1 substitution theory, while the magistrate judge found that the defendants' fraud argument did not depend on it.
Defense examiners wrote about page 1 in different terms. Tytell concluded that the document was not consistent with the normal preparation of a two-page document; the magistrate judge found that he did not state the substitution theory. Stewart for the plaintiff found no basis for a conclusion that page 1 had been substituted. LaPorte wrote that there was no evidence to refute the possibility of another original page 1.
The magistrate judge then held that "nothing in the record establishes that Defendants' fraud argument is predicated on the page 1 substitution theory." The defendants argued that the whole Work for Hire Document was a recent fabrication. Opinions aimed at the substitution theory lost weight because they answered a question the court did not have to decide.
A reviewer writes down the other side's theory in one sentence before reading the expert reports: substituted page, added entry, or a document made later in full. Each opinion is then marked as answering that theory, a different one, or none.
Who examined the original, and when?
Observations of color, paper condition and handling marks come from the original. In Ceglia the report noted which examiners were present when the document was first produced on July 14, 2011, and relied on their observations.
The report describes Tytell, a forensic document examiner, and Romano, a typeface and print technology expert, as "both of whom were present when the document was first produced" to the defendants' experts on July 14, 2011. It states that Stewart was not present at that production.
Tytell described the ink of the handwritten material as "a faded brown or light tan." Blanco offered a probable cause for the yellowing and deterioration of the document, and the magistrate judge found it unsupported. Opinions on the condition of paper and ink drew on who had seen the document and when.
For a review the dates matter as much as the names. The reviewer lists each examination session, who attended, what was done to the document and which observations were recorded at each one. A condition reported at a later session can result from handling or testing after the first.
How do laboratory report templates word alteration and print-process findings?
They name the method with the result. New York's standardized wording reads that a named method revealed the alteration, or that no differences were observed by a named method, and print-process findings list what was present.
The New York project gives three forms for an alteration finding. Positive: "(Insert method used) revealed that the document was altered in the following manner." Negative: "No differences were observed by (insert method) examination." Inconclusive: "A definitive determination could not be reached." For print process the positive form begins "Visual and microscopic examination revealed the presence of," and the inconclusive form reads "The print process cannot be determined."
The same page requires each report to give a "General indication of methodology utilized" and a "Statement regarding the report does not constitute the entire case file or equivalent." The second requirement tells the reviewer to ask for the file.
The archived Questioned Documents Unit Manual of the San Diego Police Department Crime Laboratory, approved in September 2019, states that "All case packets are Technically and Administratively reviewed prior to distribution," that "All results, even if negative, shall be noted" in its procedure for indented impressions (ESDA), and that a discrepancy found in technical review leads to a compromise opinion at the lesser level of certainty. A private examiner's report can be compared with these practices: whether a second examiner reviewed it, and whether negative results appear in the notes.
How did the court weigh the competing examiners in Ceglia?
Under a clear and convincing standard, defined as highly probable or reasonably certain. The magistrate judge noted that a factfinder need not accept expert opinions and may give little weight to opinions with defective, incomplete or questionable bases.
The report quotes Biediger v. Quinnipiac University (2d Cir. 2012) that "a factfinder is not required to accept expert opinions," and Pope v. County of Albany (2d Cir. 2012) on opinions whose "bases are defective, incomplete, or questionable." The standard for dismissal was clear and convincing evidence, "highly probable or reasonably certain."
On the ink, LaPorte concluded that it was "highly probable the ink is less than two-years old." The report noted in footnote 30 that "Plaintiff has not moved pursuant to Daubert to exclude LaPorte's opinion." Lyter reported that the ink was unsuitable for thin-layer chromatography; the magistrate judge found that this had no bearing on LaPorte's dating, because that method is not used to date ink. Stewart had done no GC/MS testing and did not explain why.
The report and recommendation, dated March 26, 2013 and signed by Magistrate Judge Leslie G. Foschio, concluded that "clear and convincing evidence establishes the StreetFax Document is the authentic contract" and recommended that the case be "dismissed with prejudice."
In federal civil cases today, a rebuttal report on the same subject is due under Rule 26(a)(2)(D)(ii) within 30 days after the other side's disclosure, absent a stipulation or order. Rule 702 requires the proponent of each opinion to show the court that it is more likely than not that the opinion rests on sufficient facts or data and a reliable application of the method.
What does IAE do when a substituted-page opinion needs review?
IAE prepares reviews of the opposing document examiner's report on alterations, substituted pages, ink or dating. The signed PDF is issued in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed, with a 48-hour rush.
The reviewer reads the report and the produced file against ANSI/ASB Standards 011 and 035, the SWGDOC ink comparison standard and Rule 26(a)(2)(B). Each point of the review cites a page of the report and a section of a standard or rule.
You approve the reviewer and the CV before work starts. The reviewer asks for the case notes and the images of each examination.
A review can be prepared first as a confidential consulting opinion. Under Rule 26(b)(4)(D), facts known and opinions held by a retained expert who is not expected to testify are ordinarily not discoverable, except as provided in Rule 35(b) or on a showing of exceptional circumstances.
Sources
- Ceglia v. Zuckerberg, No. 10-CV-569A(F) (W.D.N.Y.), Report and Recommendation of Magistrate Judge Leslie G. Foschio, March 26, 2013, Doc. 651 (Justia)
- SWGDOC Standard for Examination of Altered Documents, ver. 2013-1
- New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, NYCLAC Report Standardization Project, Questioned Documents
- San Diego Police Department Crime Laboratory, Questioned Documents Unit Manual, approved September 6, 2019 (archived)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 702, Testimony by Expert Witnesses, with Committee Notes on the 2023 Amendment (LII)
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 26, Duty to Disclose; General Provisions Governing Discovery (LII)
Read also
All articles
The government's forensic report says your document is counterfeit: how is it reviewed and rebutted in immigration proceedings?
An asylum file or a benefit application can turn on one sheet of paper: a birth certificate, a church letter, a party card. When a government
The opposing examiner says the pages came from different printers: how is that opinion reviewed?
Opinions that a page was printed on a different machine than the rest of a contract often decide substitution claims. The SWGDOC standards for toner
The opposing examiner calls the document a forgery: may a document examiner decide that?
A document examiner may testify that a signature is not the writing of the person named, that a page was replaced or that an entry was added. WhetherExpert report review
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

