Letter review
Why do EB-1A cases get denied over weak letters, and what do you fix before refiling?
Under 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3), an EB-1A petition must prove sustained national or international acclaim through a major international award or at least three of ten criteria, and the officer then weighs the whole record. In AAO decisions of 2013, 2023 and 2024, letters that praised the petitioner without naming the contribution and its effect on the field did not carry the original contributions criterion, and the appeals were dismissed.

Why do EB-1A petitions get denied?
A petition fails at one of two steps: fewer than three criteria proven, or a final merits review that finds no sustained acclaim at the very top of the field. Letters are filed as evidence for both steps.
Under 8 CFR 204.5(h)(2), extraordinary ability means "a level of expertise indicating that the individual is one of that small percentage who have risen to the very top of the field of endeavor." Paragraph (h)(3) asks for evidence "that the alien has sustained national or international acclaim" and lets the petitioner prove it by "a one-time achievement (that is, a major, international recognized award), or at least three of the following" ten criteria.
The USCIS Policy Manual then adds the final merits review. If the officer finds that eligibility is not proven, "the officer should not merely make general assertions regarding this failure" and "must articulate the specific reasons" in the written denial. A petition that meets three criteria can still be denied at this step.
Paragraph (h)(5) adds one more requirement: "clear evidence that the alien is coming to the United States to continue work in the area of expertise," such as letters from prospective employers, contracts, or a statement from the beneficiary detailing plans.
In the AAO decisions cited below, the petitions failed at the first step. On December 16, 2024, the Director had found none of the six claimed criteria met. On December 12, 2023, the petitioner had claimed five criteria and the Director had found none. On August 2, 2013, the AAO found none of the claimed criteria met. In each case the letters were filed for the criterion of original contributions of major significance.
What does a weak letter look like in an AAO decision?
It praises the person without naming the contribution, keeps the effect of the work inside one employer, repeats the wording of the regulation, or makes a claim that no document in the record supports.
On August 2, 2013 the AAO dismissed the appeal of a petitioner in the arts whose filing described his proposed employment as "Director/Producer/Writer/Instructor." It wrote: "Vague, solicited letters from local colleagues that do not specifically identify contributions or provide specific examples of how those contributions influenced the field are insufficient," citing Kazarian v. USCIS, 580 F.3d 1030, 1036 (9th Cir. 2009). It added that such letters can give details about the petitioner's skills but cannot be the main basis of a successful extraordinary ability claim.
On December 16, 2024 the AAO dismissed the appeal of an integration architect in energy efficiency who filed four recommendation letters. "Although the letters praise the Petitioner," the AAO wrote, they did not establish contributions of major significance in the field, and "the letters lack specific, detailed information explaining how the Petitioner has made original contributions." The decision recalls that USCIS "need not accept primarily conclusory statements."
The Policy Manual names the same defect: "Letters that merely reiterate USCIS' definitions relating to this classification or make general and expansive statements regarding the beneficiary and the beneficiary's accomplishments are generally not persuasive."
Why do letters about the employer's projects fail the original contributions criterion?
Criterion (h)(3)(v) asks for contributions of major significance in the field. Letters that describe gains for one employer, or patents without evidence of use, leave that significance unproven, as the AAO found in 2023 and 2024.
In the December 16, 2024 decision the AAO found that "the letters limit the relevance of the Petitioner's contributions to his employers." The letters "briefly indicate the importance of the Petitioner's contributions to his employers" and "do not further elaborate and explain how his employer projects translated into contributions of major significance in the field."
The December 12, 2023 decision concerned a petition that an artificial intelligence and natural language processing technology business filed for its software engineer. The reference letters came from individuals who worked with him. The AAO found that "the letters briefly describe the Beneficiary's projects without detailing the significance of the work in the field," and that one letter's claim concerned the limited impact on the employer and not the field as a whole.
A letter about his patents had the same gap. The AAO wrote that the author did not explain how the patents became significant in the field, and "the letter does not indicate whether any of the patents have been commercialized or utilized." The criterion was not met, so the engineer did not reach three criteria, and the AAO did not decide the leading role and high salary criteria.
The same decision noted that USCIS had approved O-1 petitions for the engineer, and that those approvals did not prevent USCIS from denying an immigrant petition. A record that won O-1 status is weighed again under 8 CFR 204.5(h).
What does the Policy Manual require of a letter?
Specific reasons why the author considers the person extraordinary, a description of the contribution and its significance to the field, the basis of the author's knowledge, and documents in the record that corroborate the statements.
Chapter 2 sets four requirements. "The letters should explain in specific terms why the witnesses believe the beneficiary to be of the caliber of a person with extraordinary ability." "Submitted letters should specifically describe the person's contribution and its significance to the field and should also set forth the basis of the writer's knowledge and expertise." And "the statements made by the witnesses should be corroborated by documentary evidence in the record."
The Policy Manual describes the place of letters in the record: letters of support, "while not without weight," should not be the foundation of a successful claim in this classification. For original contributions, "Detailed letters from experts in the field explaining the nature and significance of the person's contribution may also provide valuable context," "particularly when the record includes documentation corroborating the claimed significance."
The AAO applied these sentences in both the 2023 and the 2024 decisions. Each decision repeated, with a citation to the Policy Manual, the requirement that letters describe the contribution and its significance to the field and state the writer's basis of knowledge, and each found that the letters did not.
Does the author's relationship with the applicant matter?
Yes. The Policy Manual tells officers to consider the relationship or affiliation between the beneficiary and the witness when they weigh the letter. Colleagues can write, but their letters need documents behind them.
The sentence reads: "The relationship or affiliation between the beneficiary and the witness is also a factor the officer should consider when evaluating the significance of witnesses' statements." In the 2013 decision the AAO called the letters "solicited letters from local colleagues," and in the 2023 decision it described the authors as individuals who worked with the beneficiary.
A collaborator knows what the applicant did inside a project. An author outside the applicant's circle can confirm that others in the field used the result. The choice between the two kinds of author is covered in the guide Independent expert or collaborator: whose letter carries more weight?
Can a letter prove a criterion without documents?
No. In the 2013 decision letters that said the petitioner was invited to judge did not prove that he served as a judge, and the AAO required corroborating documents where testimony lacked detail.
Under the judging criterion, the 2013 letters "merely indicate that the authors or their organizations invited the petitioner to serve as a judge." The AAO withdrew the Director's finding that the criterion was met, because an invitation does not show that the judging took place.
The AAO cited Matter of S-A-, 22 I&N Dec. 1328, 1332 (BIA 2000), under which the BIA will "require the introduction of corroborative testimonial and documentary evidence, where available." And: "If testimonial evidence lacks specificity, detail, or credibility, there is a greater need for the petitioner to submit corroborative evidence."
On expert opinions the AAO relied on Matter of Caron International, 19 I&N Dec. 791, 795: USCIS "may, in its discretion, use as advisory opinions statements submitted as expert testimony," but USCIS "is ultimately responsible for making the final determination," and letters from experts are not presumptive evidence of eligibility. USCIS "may evaluate the content of those letters as to whether they support the alien's eligibility."
What else sinks an EB-1A petition besides letters?
Documents that do not meet the filing rules. In the 2013 case the awards and display criteria failed because the translations were deficient, and the regulation requires a certified full English translation of every foreign-language document.
Under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(3), "Any document containing foreign language submitted to USCIS shall be accompanied by a full English language translation which the translator has certified as complete and accurate, and by the translator's certification that he or she is competent to translate from the foreign language into English."
In the 2013 case the Director had found the display criterion met. The AAO found that the record did not support that finding, because the Director had relied on translations that did not comply with 103.2(b)(3) and therefore "have significantly diminished probative value." The awards criterion failed on the same translations and on the lack of primary evidence of a 2010 career award.
Published material has a format rule in the regulation itself. Criterion (h)(3)(iii) counts "Published material about the alien" relating to the alien's work, and "Such evidence shall include the title, date, and author of the material, and any necessary translation." An article that names the company and not the applicant, or a printout without a date, leaves the criterion open.
After a denial over letters, is an appeal or a new petition the better fix?
An appeal and a motion to reconsider argue the existing record, and a motion to reopen adds new facts, all within 30 days. A new I-140 brings rewritten letters and is judged at its own filing date.
Under 8 CFR 103.3(a)(2)(i), the complete appeal on Form I-290B, with any brief, is due "within 30 days after service of the decision." Under (a)(1)(v), an officer "shall summarily dismiss any appeal when the party concerned fails to identify specifically" an erroneous conclusion of law or statement of fact. Under 8 CFR 103.5(a)(1)(i), a motion to reopen or to reconsider is filed within 30 days of the decision, and under (a)(2) a motion to reopen "must state the new facts to be provided in the reopened proceeding."
In two EB-1A cases the brief did not reach the AAO. On May 21, 2024 the AAO dismissed combined motions to reopen and reconsider. In November 2023 it had summarily dismissed the appeal, which did not identify specifically any erroneous conclusion of law, and the supplemental brief had been sent to Tempe, Arizona, and not to the AAO. On December 12, 2024 it dismissed motions in a case where the Director denied the petition on February 29, 2024 and the AAO summarily dismissed the appeal on August 23, 2024. The petitioner's brief, dated April 15, 2024, had gone to the Vermont Service Center. That decision quotes the rule: "Any brief and/or evidence submitted after the filing of an appeal must be sent directly to the AAO."
A new petition answers the denial with new evidence. Under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(1), the petitioner must be eligible at the time of filing, so the new letters may describe achievements up to the new filing date. The AAO procedure for appeals and motions is set out in the article NIW denied after an RFE: appeal, motion or a new petition?, and it applies to I-140 denials in EB-1A in the same way.
What do you fix in the letters before refiling?
Every finding in the denial that names a letter. Each rewritten letter names the contribution, its date and its use outside the employer, states the author's basis of knowledge and relationship, and points to an exhibit for each fact.
The denial is the work list, because the Policy Manual requires the officer to articulate specific reasons. The rewrite follows seven steps.
- Copy every sentence of the denial that mentions a letter or a criterion supported by letters.
- For each letter, mark the contribution it claims and check whether the letter names it in one sentence with a date.
- Replace statements of importance to the employer with facts about use outside it: licensees, adopters, citing authors, standards or products that took up the result.
- Attach the document behind each fact, such as a contract, a citation report, a license or press with a named author and date.
- Add the author's basis of knowledge and the author's relationship with the applicant in the first paragraph.
- Delete sentences that restate the regulation, because the Policy Manual calls such letters generally not persuasive.
- Check every foreign-language exhibit for a full certified English translation under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(3).
How does an IAE review check the letters before the new filing?
A reviewer from the IAE registry, independent of the letter's provider, checks each letter page by page against the criteria of the category and returns a signed 3-5 page review with a verdict: file, revise or redo.
The IAE expert letter review is an independent check of an expert opinion letter or a credential evaluation before filing with USCIS. Among four situations, the service page names the review after an RFE: it answers whether the officer's findings stem from a weak expert letter and what exactly to strengthen.
Every section of the letter is checked against the criteria of the visa category, and the credentials and relevance of the signing expert are assessed separately. The review lists specific weak points with a way to strengthen each, and the applicant and the attorney revise the letter from that list. It ends with one of three verdicts, each with reasoning: file, revise or redo.
IAE reviews letters from any company. The reviewer is an IAE registry member in the letter's field, is independent of the provider of the document under review and confirms this in writing, and the materials are kept confidential.
To order, send the letter or the evaluation with a short description of the petition. The secretariat confirms the fee, the turnaround and the reviewer within one business day, and the fee depends on the visa category and the volume of materials. The standard turnaround is 3 business days from payment and receipt of all materials, or 1 business day on the rush option. IAE is not a law firm, and USCIS decides the petition.
Sources
- 8 CFR 204.5, Petitions for employment-based immigrants (eCFR)
- USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 2, Extraordinary Ability
- 8 CFR 103.2, Submission and adjudication of benefit requests (eCFR)
- 8 CFR 103.3, Denials, appeals, and precedent decisions (eCFR)
- 8 CFR 103.5, Reopening or reconsideration (eCFR)
- AAO non-precedent decision, I-140 extraordinary ability, August 2, 2013
- AAO non-precedent decision, I-140 extraordinary ability, December 12, 2023
- AAO non-precedent decision, I-140 extraordinary ability, December 16, 2024
- AAO non-precedent decision, I-140 extraordinary ability, motions, December 12, 2024
- AAO non-precedent decision, I-140 extraordinary ability, motions, May 21, 2024
Read also
All articles
Indian three-year bachelor's plus two-year master's: does USCIS count it as an advanced degree for EB-2?
In AAO decisions of 2017 and 2019 an Indian master's degree was placed at the level of a U.S. bachelor's degree. In 2017 the AAO cited EDGE. In 2019
Foreign medical degree (MBBS or MD) for USCIS: when is it an advanced degree, and what must the evaluation show?
A U.S. medical degree is an advanced degree for USCIS because U.S. medical schools admit students after a bachelor's. Many foreign schools admit them
USCIS cited AACRAO EDGE against your credential evaluation: what happens next?
When a credential evaluation and the AACRAO EDGE database disagree, USCIS may follow EDGE. In Viraj v. U.S. Attorney General (11th Cir. 2014)Expert letter review
Check the letter before the officer does
The standard turnaround is 3 business days, the rush option 1 business day. The fee depends on the visa category and the volume of materials; we confirm the fee, the turnaround and the reviewer within one business day.

