EB-1A
EB-1A and O-1 without publications or citations: which criteria fit an industry profile?
Neither 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3) for EB-1A nor 8 CFR 214.2(o)(3)(iii) for O-1A requires publications or citations. Authorship of scholarly articles is one criterion out of ten in EB-1A and one out of eight in O-1A. An engineer, product manager, executive or founder can prove a leading or critical role, a high salary, judging and business-related contributions with work records. Where a criterion does not readily apply to the occupation, both regulations allow comparable evidence.

Do EB-1A and O-1A require publications or citations?
No. Authorship of scholarly articles is one of ten EB-1A criteria and one of eight O-1A criteria, and none of the criteria mentions citations. A petition needs a major award or at least three criteria.
Under 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3), an EB-1A petition needs "a one-time achievement (that is, a major, international recognized award), or at least three of the following" ten types of evidence. The sixth is "Evidence of the alien's authorship of scholarly articles in the field, in professional or major trade publications or other major media" (8 CFR 204.5(h)(3)(vi)). For O-1A, 8 CFR 214.2(o)(3)(iii) asks for a major international award or "At least three of the following forms of documentation," and the sixth of eight is authorship of scholarly articles (8 CFR 214.2(o)(3)(iii)(B)(6)).
In Kazarian v. USCIS the Ninth Circuit held on March 4, 2010 that "neither USCIS nor an AAO may unilaterally impose novel substantive or evidentiary requirements beyond those set forth at 8 C.F.R. § 204.5" (596 F.3d 1115). Citations by other authors, the court wrote, "might be relevant to the final merits determination" but are "not relevant to the antecedent procedural question of whether the petitioner has provided at least three types of evidence." Both steps are covered in the guide The Kazarian two-step review: why three EB-1A criteria are not enough.
Which criteria can an industry record meet?
Four criteria in both categories can be proved with employment and business records: a leading or critical role, a high salary, judging and business-related contributions. The wording differs between EB-1A and O-1A.
Trade press counts in both categories. EB-1A item (iii) covers "Published material about the alien in professional or major trade publications or other major media," and O-1A item (3) covers "Published material in professional or major trade publications or major media about the alien." Both require "the title, date, and author" of the material.
The four criteria read as follows in 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3) and 8 CFR 214.2(o)(3)(iii)(B).
- EB-1A item (viii) asks for "a leading or critical role for organizations or establishments that have a distinguished reputation," and O-1A item (7) asks for employment "in a critical or essential capacity" for such organizations.
- EB-1A item (ix) covers "a high salary or other significantly high remuneration for services, in relation to others in the field," and O-1A item (8) also covers an applicant who "will command a high salary," proved by "contracts or other reliable evidence."
- EB-1A item (iv) and O-1A item (4) both cover participation "as a judge of the work of others" in the same or an allied field.
- EB-1A item (v) and O-1A item (5) both list "business-related contributions of major significance in the field."
How does USCIS assess a leading or critical role?
In two steps: whether the role was leading or critical, and whether the organization, division or department has a distinguished reputation. For a critical role the Policy Manual looks at performance, and the title does not decide.
Under the USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 2, "A title, with appropriate matching duties, can help to establish that a role is (or was), in fact, leading." In a critical role the person contributed "in a way that is of significant importance to the outcome" of the organization's activities. "It is not the title of the person's role, but rather the person's performance in the role that determines whether the role is (or was) critical."
Size and longevity do not settle the organization's reputation on their own. Other factors "can include the scale of its customer base or relevant media coverage," and for a startup, significant funding counts as a positive factor when it is "commensurate with funding rounds generally achieved for that startup's stage and industry."
On June 12, 2024 the AAO found the criterion met for "a web developer and digital marketing entrepreneur" (In Re: 31109123). The Director of the USCIS service center had found no "objective, documentary evidence" of a leading role. The AAO relied on an excerpt from the internal rules of her Russian company, which "lists her responsibilities as CEO," on "government and tax records showing that she solely owns and founded the company" and on regional Internet awards. "The record lacks evidence of the scale of the company's client base," the AAO wrote, and concluded: "A preponderance of the evidence establishes the Petitioner's leading role with a distinguished company." With two criteria found by the Director, she reached three, and the case went back for a final merits determination.
How do you prove a high salary?
By comparing the pay with what others in the field earn, using surveys that match the position and location. A credible contract or job offer can count. In December 2024 the AAO rejected a survey without salary ranges or percentiles.
Under the Policy Manual, "USCIS determines whether the person's salary or remuneration is high relative to the compensation paid to others working in the field." The pay need not have been received yet: "a credible contract or job offer showing prospective salary or remuneration may establish that the person has been able to command such compensation." The comparison may rest on "geographical or position-appropriate compensation surveys and organizational justifications to pay above the compensation data."
On December 18, 2024 the AAO dismissed the appeal of an applicant described as "a CEO/manager/entrepreneur" (In Re: 33564231). Her Glassdoor printout for "technical responsible nurses in Brazil" was "based on only 20 submitted wages" and did not separate regions, experience levels or employer types. Her Salario.com survey covered "workers employed eight years after the Petitioner left her position." Her pay was above the survey average, and the AAO still found the criterion unmet: "the survey does not provide salary ranges, percentiles, or other means of establishing whether this difference was sufficiently significant to qualify for this criterion."
What counts as judging and as a business-related contribution?
Judging counts when the applicant actually reviewed others' work in the same or an allied field, and an invitation alone falls short. A business-related contribution must have major significance in the field, for example through commercialization.
For judging, the Policy Manual requires proof that the person actually took part in the judging, and an invitation is not enough. Its example is peer review, documented by the journal's request together with evidence "confirming that the person actually completed the review." An applicant who judged outside journals can file the same two documents: the organizer's invitation and a record that the review was done.
For original contributions, funding, a patent or a publication "will not necessarily establish, on its own, that the work is of major significance to the field." A patented technology "that has attracted significant attention or commercialization may establish the significance" of the contribution, and use of the work by other companies is covered in the guide Original contributions of major significance in EB-1A: how do you prove them?
When can you file comparable evidence?
When a criterion does not readily apply to the applicant's occupation. The petitioner explains why in a detailed and specific statement and offers evidence of comparable significance. There is no comparable evidence for a one-time major award.
The EB-1A rule reads: "If the above standards do not readily apply to the beneficiary's occupation, the petitioner may submit comparable evidence to establish the beneficiary's eligibility" (8 CFR 204.5(h)(4)). The O-1A rule, 8 CFR 214.2(o)(3)(iii)(C), uses nearly the same words for the criteria in paragraph (o)(3)(iii).
The Policy Manual tells officers to decide whether the criteria "are readily applicable to the person's occupation and, if not, whether the evidence provided is truly comparable." A criterion "need not be entirely inapplicable"; it is enough that it is "not easily applicable to the person's job or profession." A statement from the petitioner can settle the first question "if that statement is detailed, specific, and credible." "A general unsupported assertion" that a criterion does not apply "is not probative," and "general claims that USCIS should accept witness letters as comparable evidence are not persuasive." The Policy Manual adds: "There is no comparable evidence for the one-time achievement of a major, international recognized award."
Two examples in the Policy Manual come from outside academia. If scholarly articles are not readily applicable to a person "whose occupation is in an industry rather than academia," the petitioner might prove that "the person's presentation of work at a major trade show is of comparable significance to that criterion." If a high salary is not readily applicable to an entrepreneur's position, the petitioner might present evidence "that the person's highly valued equity holdings in the startup are of comparable significance to the high salary criterion."
On June 30, 2023 the AAO dismissed the appeal of a civil engineer with "approximately 20 years of professional experience with employers in Pakistan and United Arab Emirates, primarily working in the construction engineering field" (In Re: 26842681). He relied on "recognition by authorities in his field as an engineer of extraordinary ability," which is not a regulatory criterion. "Here, the Petitioner has not articulated a comparable evidence claim," the AAO wrote. It weighed his letters under criterion (v) and found fewer than three criteria met.
What happens after an industry applicant meets three criteria?
The officer weighs the whole record and decides whether the applicant has sustained national or international acclaim and stands at the very top of the field. In November 2024 an energy executive met three criteria and lost his appeal.
The Policy Manual says that "objectively meeting the regulatory criteria in the first step alone does not establish that the person in fact meets the requirements for classification as a person with extraordinary ability."
On November 22, 2024 the AAO ruled on "an executive in the energy industry," executive vice president of completions at a Texas maker of oil and gas components (In Re: 35432503). The Director and the AAO had found the leading or critical role and high salary criteria met. In September 2024 the AAO reopened the matter on a service motion, and the new evidence met the judging criterion.
At the final merits step the AAO accepted that he "has held leading roles in organizations with a distinguished reputation" but found no proof of how this "has led to sustained national or international acclaim or placed him at the very top of his field." On judging it wrote: "He did not show, for example, how his experience in evaluating subordinate engineers compares to others at the very top of the field of endeavor." His income for 2013 to 2022 was in the record, without a comparison with others at the top of his field. The appeal was dismissed.
What should an expert letter on industry work say?
The applicant's results, the records that prove them, their significance for the field and the basis of the author's knowledge. Under the Policy Manual, letters with general and expansive statements are generally not persuasive.
Under the Policy Manual, "the statements made by the witnesses should be corroborated by documentary evidence in the record." Letters that "make general and expansive statements regarding the beneficiary and the beneficiary's accomplishments are generally not persuasive." The officer also weighs "the relationship or affiliation between the beneficiary and the witness."
Two kinds of letters do different work. For criterion (viii) the Policy Manual says that letters "from persons with personal knowledge of the significance of the person's leading or critical role can be particularly helpful to officers" when they are detailed and specific about the role. For criterion (v), "Detailed letters from experts in the field explaining the nature and significance of the person's contribution may also provide valuable context," and they "should also set forth the basis of the writer's knowledge and expertise."
An expert letter that retells the CV repeats the exhibits. A letter that adds to the record names the result, cites the exhibit that records it, says what changed outside the applicant's employer and compares the result with the level of the field. The author's tie to the applicant is covered in the guide Independent expert or collaborator: whose letter carries more weight?
How does IAE prepare an expert letter for an EB-1A or O-1 petition?
For an IAE expert opinion letter, the secretariat prepares a draft from the applicant's documents, and a registry expert in the subject area checks it, makes changes and signs it. For EB-1A and O-1 the expert assesses the contribution, originality and recognition against the level of the field, including measurable results and industry recognition. The expert's CV and a declaration of independence are attached, and the expert's status can be checked in the public IAE registry by QR code.
IAE is not a law firm and does not promise that a letter will meet any criterion. A licensed immigration attorney sets the case strategy, and USCIS weighs the letter with the rest of the record and decides the petition.
How do you prepare an industry record before filing?
Choose the criteria by their text and attach to each one documents made by others, such as employer letters and pay surveys. Write any comparable evidence statement separately for each criterion.
The preparation takes six steps.
- Write one sentence per claimed criterion naming the documents that meet each condition in its text.
- For a leading or critical role, file the organization chart, an employer letter on duties and results, and evidence of the organization's reputation.
- For a high salary, file pay records and a survey for the same position and location with ranges or percentiles.
- For judging, file the invitation and the record that the review was completed.
- For comparable evidence, name the criterion, explain in detail why it does not readily apply to the occupation and say why the substitute has comparable significance.
- Check every sentence of every letter against an exhibit.
What if you are not sure which criteria your record meets?
The IAE profile audit answers that in writing. An IAE expert checks the achievements against the criteria of the chosen category: EB-1A, EB-2 NIW or O-1. For each criterion the report says whether it is met, partly met or not met and names the documents behind the conclusion, and it lists missing or weak evidence and what to obtain before filing. The audit gives no legal advice and no forecast of the USCIS decision.
Sources
- 8 CFR 204.5, Petitions for employment-based immigrants (eCFR)
- 8 CFR 214.2, paragraph (o), O-1 classification (Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School)
- USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 2, Extraordinary Ability
- Kazarian v. USCIS, 596 F.3d 1115 (9th Cir. 2010), No. 07-56774, amended opinion filed March 4, 2010
- AAO non-precedent decision, In Re: 26842681, June 30, 2023
- AAO non-precedent decision, In Re: 31109123, June 12, 2024
- AAO non-precedent decision, In Re: 35432503, November 22, 2024
- AAO non-precedent decision, In Re: 33564231, December 18, 2024
Read also
All guides
Original contributions of major significance in EB-1A: how do you prove them?
Criterion (v) of the EB-1A regulation asks for original contributions of major significance in the field. USCIS decides two things: whether the work
Association membership as an EB-1A and O-1 criterion: which memberships count?
EB-1A and O-1A petitions both list membership in associations among the evidentiary criteria. The criterion is narrow. The association has to require
The Kazarian two-step review: why three EB-1A criteria are not enough
In Kazarian v. USCIS, decided on March 4, 2010, the Ninth Circuit separated two questions in an EB-1A case: whether the evidence meets at least threeGuides
Case assessment in 1 business day
Tell us the petition category, field and deadline. The Secretariat replies within one business day: which letters make sense, who checks and signs them and what they cost.
Are you an expert thinking about IAE membership? One-minute eligibility check

