EB-1A
The ten EB-1A criteria under 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3): what evidence does USCIS accept for each?
An EB-1A petition must show either one major, internationally recognized award or at least three of the ten types of evidence listed in 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3). USCIS first checks each claimed criterion against its text, then weighs all the evidence together. This guide takes the criteria one by one: the wording of the regulation, the points the USCIS Policy Manual tells officers to check and the documents that answer them.

What does 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3) require?
Evidence of sustained national or international acclaim: either a one-time achievement, meaning a major, internationally recognized award, or at least three of ten listed types of evidence. Three criteria open the second step of review; the decision is made there.
The classification comes from 8 U.S.C. 1153(b)(1)(A). The statute sets three conditions. The person has extraordinary ability shown by "sustained national or international acclaim," and the achievements are recognized in the field through "extensive documentation." The person seeks to enter the United States to continue work in the area of that ability. The entry will "substantially benefit prospectively the United States."
The regulation, 8 CFR 204.5(h), turns the first condition into a list of evidence. Paragraph (h)(2) defines extraordinary ability as a level of expertise showing that the person is "one of that small percentage who have risen to the very top of the field of endeavor." Paragraph (h)(3) asks for evidence of a one-time achievement or "at least three of the following" ten types.
Two more paragraphs complete the rule. Under (h)(4), if the listed standards do not readily apply to the occupation, "the petitioner may submit comparable evidence to establish the beneficiary's eligibility." Under (h)(5), no job offer or labor certification is required, but the petition must contain "clear evidence that the alien is coming to the United States to continue work in the area of expertise," such as letters from prospective employers, prearranged contracts or a statement of plans.
The USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 2 gives the Nobel Prize as an example of a one-time achievement and closes the other door: "There is no comparable evidence for the one-time achievement of a major, international recognized award." Almost every petition therefore rests on the ten criteria below.
- (i) lesser nationally or internationally recognized prizes or awards for excellence in the field;
- (ii) membership in associations that require outstanding achievements of their members;
- (iii) published material about the person in professional or major trade publications or other major media;
- (iv) participation as a judge of the work of others;
- (v) original contributions of major significance;
- (vi) authorship of scholarly articles;
- (vii) display of the person's work at artistic exhibitions;
- (viii) a leading or critical role for organizations with a distinguished reputation;
- (ix) a high salary or other significantly high remuneration;
- (x) commercial successes in the performing arts.
How does USCIS review the ten criteria?
In two steps. First the officer checks whether the evidence objectively meets the text of each claimed criterion. Then, in a final merits determination, the officer weighs everything together against the definition of extraordinary ability.
The two steps come from Kazarian v. USCIS, an amended opinion the Ninth Circuit filed on March 4, 2010 (No. 07-56774). The Administrative Appeals Office had refused to count the applicant's scholarly articles because other researchers had not cited them, and it had discounted his judging of diploma works because he judged at his own university. The court held that both readings added requirements the regulation does not contain.
The court said the citation record and the university affiliation might matter later, in deciding whether the applicant is at the very top of his field, and did not matter to the question of whether he had submitted three types of evidence. It counted two types where the agency had counted none. Three were needed, so the denial stood.
The Policy Manual follows the same order. At the first step the officer decides whether each item meets the plain wording of its criterion. At the second step the officer considers the petition as a whole under the preponderance of the evidence standard. The steps are set out in the guide to the Kazarian two-step review.
What does this mean for the way a petition is written?
Each criterion is argued by its own words, with a document for every condition in the text. Arguments about how strong the record is belong to the second step, where the officer reads everything together.
What evidence meets criterion (i), prizes or awards?
Proof that the person, and not the employer, received a prize or award recognized nationally or internationally for excellence in the field. Awards open only within one locality, employer or school carry little recognition.
The regulation asks for documentation of the person's receipt of "lesser nationally or internationally recognized prizes or awards for excellence" in the field of endeavor. The word "lesser" sets these awards against the one-time achievement named in the same paragraph.
Under the Policy Manual the officer checks two things: that the person received the award, and that the award is recognized nationally or internationally for excellence. The focus is on the person's own award. An award to the employer does not count for an employee.
The Manual describes what moves an award up or down. An award open only within a single locality, employer or school may have little national or international recognition. An award open to members of a well-known national institution, including an R1 or R2 doctoral university, or of a professional organization may be nationally recognized. Limits on who may compete are relevant without being disqualifying: awards "limited to youth, amateur competitors, or early-career professionals" can qualify.
A team award counts when the person is one of its recipients. The Manual's signs of that are a trophy, certificate or medal for each member, an appearance on the podium or stage, or the person's name in the announcement. An acknowledgment from the recipient alone does not make another person a recipient.
- the certificate or the official announcement that names the person;
- the award's published rules: who may compete and how the winner is chosen;
- evidence that the award is known in the field nationally or internationally, such as coverage in national or trade media;
- for a team award, the document that lists the person among the recipients.
What evidence meets criterion (ii), membership in associations?
Proof that the association requires outstanding achievements of its members and that recognized national or international experts judge those achievements. The officer reads the admission rules of the membership level the person holds.
The text has two conditions. The association must "require outstanding achievements of their members," and the achievements must be assessed "as judged by recognized national or international experts in their disciplines or fields." An association that admits anyone who applies and pays meets neither condition.
The Policy Manual tells officers to look at the level of membership. General membership in an association may not qualify, while a higher level such as fellow may, if that level requires outstanding achievement judged by recognized experts. The Manual's example is a fellow level decided by a council of experts and a committee of current fellows. The petitioner has to show how the person's own level was earned.
The Manual also says a membership does not qualify when it was granted solely on grounds other than outstanding achievement. The conditions and typical refusals are covered in the guide to association membership as a criterion.
- the bylaws or admission rules for the person's membership level;
- the document that shows who decides on admission and the standing of those people in the field;
- the membership certificate or letter with the level and the date of admission.
What evidence meets criterion (iii), published material about the person?
Articles or broadcasts about the person and the person's work in the field, in professional or major trade publications or other major media, filed with the title, date and author and a translation where one is needed.
The regulation requires published material "in professional or major trade publications or other major media" that relates to the person's work in the field, and it lists what must accompany each item: the title, the date, the author and any necessary translation.
The Policy Manual draws the line between the person and the organization. The material should be about the person, and material about the employer alone does not count. An article about a team's work can count if it mentions the person in connection with that work, or if other evidence in the record shows the person's significant role in it.
Marketing material is generally not counted, and the Manual includes content that looks objective but was paid for by the person or the employer. Print and online newspaper and magazine articles are named as acceptable forms.
Whether a publication is professional, major trade or major media is a separate question. For professional and major trade publications officers consider the intended audience. For major trade publications and other major media they consider circulation, readership or viewership relative to other outlets.
- a copy of each item with the title, date and author visible;
- a certified translation of any item in another language;
- data on the outlet: its audience and its circulation, readership or viewership compared with others;
- for a team story, the passage that names the person and a document on the person's part in the work.
What evidence meets criterion (iv), judging the work of others?
Proof that the person actually judged the work of others, alone or on a panel, in the same or an allied field. An invitation to review without a completed review does not meet the criterion.
The regulation covers participation "as a judge of the work of others in the same or an allied field of specification," either individually or on a panel.
The Policy Manual asks for actual participation. Its example is peer review for a journal: the journal's request to review, together with evidence confirming that the review was completed. An invitation alone proves only that the person was asked.
Kazarian settled one point about this criterion. The agency had discounted judging at the applicant's own university. The Ninth Circuit found nothing in the regulation that ties the criterion to where the judge works, so such judging counts at the first step. Its weight is assessed at the second step.
- the invitation or request to review;
- the confirmation that the review was completed, such as the editor's acknowledgment or the reviewer record;
- for a panel or jury, the organizer's letter or the published list of judges with the date and the event.
What evidence meets criterion (v), original contributions of major significance?
Two showings: the contribution is original, and it is of major significance in the field. Funding, a patent or a publication does not establish major significance; evidence of what the field did with the work does.
The text reads "original scientific, scholarly, artistic, athletic, or business-related contributions of major significance" in the field. Under the Policy Manual the officer first decides whether the person made original contributions and then whether they are of major significance.
For the second question the Manual names several kinds of evidence: widespread commentary on the work, a high number of citations, significant attention in the field or commercialization. Funding, patents and publications alone do not establish significance, and a pending patent application generally needs additional support, such as detailed letters from experts.
For this criterion the Manual says expert letters should describe the contribution, explain its significance and state the basis of the writer's knowledge. The documents and the typical refusals are covered in the guide to original contributions of major significance.
- the document that fixes the contribution and its date: the article, the patent or the first contract;
- records of use by others: citing papers, licenses, sales, standards or protocols that name the method;
- letters from experts that describe the use that has already happened and how the writer knows of it.
What evidence meets criterion (vi), scholarly articles?
The person's own scholarly articles in the field, published in professional or major trade publications or other major media. Citations are not required at this step: in Kazarian the court rejected that added requirement.
The regulation asks for evidence of "authorship of scholarly articles in the field, in professional or major trade publications" or other major media.
The Policy Manual describes a scholarly article as one that reports original research or philosophical discourse, is usually peer reviewed and is written for learned persons in the field. The publication itself must be professional, major trade or major media. A footnote in the chapter notes that peer-reviewed conference proceedings may qualify as scholarly articles.
In Kazarian the agency had demanded proof that other researchers cited the applicant's articles. The court held that nothing in the regulation requires evidence of the research community's reaction before articles count. Citations return at the second step, where the Manual lists a high citation rate relative to others and articles in highly ranked journals among the positive factors.
- the first page of each article with the journal, the date and the list of authors;
- evidence that the journal or the proceedings are peer reviewed;
- for the second step, citation counts and journal rankings with the source and the date of the data.
What evidence meets criteria (vii) and (x), exhibitions and commercial success?
Criterion (vii) needs the person's own work displayed at an artistic venue. Criterion (x) needs sales or box office figures in the performing arts, compared with others. Both criteria are written for the arts.
Criterion (vii) covers "display of the alien's work in the field at artistic exhibitions" and similar art venues. Under the Policy Manual the work must be the person's own product and the venue must be artistic in nature. A footnote adds that evidence of display at an artistic exhibition satisfies the criterion regardless of the caliber or significance of the exhibition; that question belongs to the second step.
Displays outside the arts do not meet the text; under the Manual they can be filed only as comparable evidence. In Kazarian the court upheld the agency's finding that the applicant's evidence did not meet criterion (vii).
Criterion (x) asks for commercial successes in the performing arts, shown by "box office receipts or record, cassette, compact disk, or video sales." The Manual looks at the volume of sales and receipts relative to others in similar pursuits. Recording music or appearing in a production does not meet the criterion without those figures.
- for (vii): the exhibition catalogue or program that names the person's work, with the venue and the dates;
- for (x): sales or box office reports from the distributor, the venue or an industry chart, with figures for comparable works.
What evidence meets criterion (viii), a leading or critical role?
Proof of two things: the role was leading or critical, and the organization, division or department has a distinguished reputation. A title supports a leading role. A critical role is shown by what the person's work changed.
The regulation speaks of a "leading or critical role for organizations or establishments that have a distinguished reputation." The Policy Manual applies it to a division or department as well as to a whole organization.
For a leading role the Manual asks whether the person is or was a leader within the organization or the unit; a matching title and duties help to show it. For a critical role it asks whether the person's contribution was of significant importance to the outcome of the organization's activities. Performance counts more than the title, and a supporting role can qualify.
The role is shown through letters from employers. Letters from other people with personal knowledge of the work also help when they are detailed and specific. For this criterion the Manual says letters should describe the role, explain its significance and state the basis of the writer's knowledge.
The reputation of the organization is a separate showing. Size and longevity are not decisive alone and are weighed with other information, such as the scale of the customer base and relevant media coverage. For academic departments and programs, national rankings and government research grants are positive factors. For a startup, significant funding from government entities, venture capital, angel investors or similar funders, in line with its stage and industry, is a positive factor.
- the employer's letter with the title, the duties, the dates and the results of the person's work;
- the organization chart that shows the person's place and reporting lines;
- evidence of the organization's reputation: rankings, media coverage, customer base, grants or funding rounds.
What evidence meets criterion (ix), a high salary?
Pay records or a credible contract or job offer, set against what others in the field earn. The regulation measures pay "in relation to others in the field," so the comparison has to match the position and the place.
The text reads "high salary or other significantly high remuneration for services, in relation to others in the field." The Policy Manual has the officer compare the person's remuneration with that of others working in the field.
The Manual names compensation surveys that are appropriate to the position or to the geographical area, and it accepts an organization's explanation of why it pays the person above the survey figures. A credible contract or job offer can show that the person is able to command such pay in the future. For startups the officer also weighs the company's funding when judging how credible the offer or contract is.
Equity is treated under comparable evidence. For an entrepreneur, highly valued equity holdings in a startup may be comparable in significance to a high salary.
- pay statements, tax records or the signed contract with the amount;
- a compensation survey for the same occupation and area, with percentiles or ranges and the survey date;
- the employer's letter on the components of pay, including bonuses and equity.
When does USCIS accept comparable evidence under 8 CFR 204.5(h)(4)?
When a listed criterion does not readily apply to the person's occupation and the petitioner explains why in detail. The substitute must be comparable in significance to the criterion it replaces.
Paragraph (h)(4) applies criterion by criterion. Under the Policy Manual a general unsupported assertion that a criterion does not readily apply to the occupation is not probative. A detailed, specific and credible statement from the petitioner can establish it.
The Manual gives two examples from science and technology. For a person in industry, a presentation at a major trade show can be comparable to the publication of scholarly articles. For an entrepreneur, highly valued equity in a startup can be comparable to a high salary. A general request to accept witness letters as comparable evidence is not persuasive.
Each substitute stands in for the one criterion that the petitioner has shown does not readily apply. How people in industry build such a record is covered in the guide to an industry profile without publications.
What does USCIS weigh after three criteria are met?
All the evidence together: whether it shows sustained national or international acclaim and a place among the small percentage at the very top of the field. The standard of proof is the preponderance of the evidence.
At the second step the Policy Manual directs the officer to consider the petition in its entirety, including relevant evidence that fits none of the ten criteria. An officer may not deny a petition merely because a particular type of evidence is absent when the evidence submitted meets the requirements. The petitioner, for its part, has to explain the significance of what it files.
The Manual lists factors that weigh in the person's favor at this step and adds that none of them is required.
A denial must state its reasons. The officer has to explain specifically why the petitioner has not shown extraordinary ability by a preponderance of the evidence.
- articles in highly ranked journals or conference proceedings, in particular as the principal contributor, the senior author or the sole author;
- a high citation rate relative to others in the field, such as a high h-index;
- employment or research at leading institutions, such as R1 or R2 universities or comparable foreign universities;
- unsolicited invitations to speak or present at nationally or internationally recognized conferences;
- being named an investigator on a peer-reviewed, competitively funded U.S. government research grant or stipend in science and technology.
What can expert letters prove for the ten criteria?
Letters explain the significance of documents that are already in the record. The Policy Manual says they are "not without weight" and must be corroborated by documentary evidence. A letter that only repeats the regulation is generally not persuasive.
The Policy Manual says letters should explain specifically why the writer considers the person extraordinary. Letters that merely repeat the regulatory definitions or make general, sweeping statements are generally not persuasive. The writer's relationship to the person affects the weight the letter receives.
Two criteria depend on letters more than the others: original contributions under (v) and a leading or critical role under (viii). For both, the Manual expects the letter to describe the contribution or the role, to explain its significance and to state how the writer knows the facts.
An independent expert opinion letter is one piece of evidence among the others, and USCIS makes the decision on the whole record. How officers read such letters is covered in the guide to the evaluation of expert opinion letters.
How do you check the record against the ten criteria before filing?
Go criterion by criterion: copy its text, list the documents that answer each condition and drop the criteria where a condition has no document. Then read the whole record as the officer will at the second step.
The check takes six steps. In IAE's profile audit an expert checks the applicant's achievements against these criteria and sends a written report: what the documents already prove, what is missing and which evidence to collect. The report comes within 5 business days after the materials and payment are received.
- Write out the text of every criterion you plan to claim and mark each condition in it.
- Put next to each condition the document that answers it. A condition without a document is a gap.
- Keep the criteria with no gaps: at the first step an item that misses a condition of the text is not counted.
- For each criterion that does not readily apply to the occupation, decide whether a detailed statement and a substitute of comparable significance can be filed under (h)(4).
- Check every statement in every letter against a document in the record.
- Read the record as a whole and write down, in one paragraph, what shows acclaim that has lasted and a place at the top of the field.
Sources
- 8 CFR 204.5, Petitions for employment-based immigrants, paragraph (h) (Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School)
- 8 U.S.C. 1153, Allocation of immigrant visas, subsection (b)(1)(A) (Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School)
- USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 2, Extraordinary Ability
- Kazarian v. USCIS, 596 F.3d 1115 (9th Cir. 2010), No. 07-56774, amended opinion filed March 4, 2010
Read also
All guides
The Kazarian two-step review: why three EB-1A criteria are not enough
In Kazarian v. USCIS, decided on March 4, 2010, the Ninth Circuit separated two questions in an EB-1A case: whether the evidence meets at least three
Original contributions of major significance in EB-1A: how do you prove them?
Criterion (v) of the EB-1A regulation asks for original contributions of major significance in the field. USCIS decides two things: whether the work
Association membership as an EB-1A and O-1 criterion: which memberships count?
EB-1A and O-1A petitions both list membership in associations among the evidentiary criteria. The criterion is narrow. The association has to requireGuides
Case assessment in 1 business day
Tell us the petition category, field and deadline. The Secretariat replies within one business day: which letters make sense, who checks and signs them and what they cost.
Are you an expert thinking about IAE membership? One-minute eligibility check

